HomeMy WebLinkAbout04-04-06
City of Farmington
325 Oak Street
Farmington, MN 55024
Mission Statement
Through teamwork and cooperation,
the City of Farmington provides quality
services that preserve our proud past and
foster a promisingfuture.
AGENDA
HERITAGE PRESERVATION COMMISSION
SPECIAL MEETING
April 4, 2006
5:30 P.M.
CITY HALL CONFERENCE ROOM
1. Call to order
2. Approval of agenda
3. Approval of minutes of February 28,2006 regular meeting
4. Public Hearings - none
5. Reports - none
6. Unfinished Business - none
7. New Business
a. Review of Swanson Acres Preliminary Plat
b. State and Local Historic Preservation Designation
8. Miscellaneous
9. Adjourn
2-11-5: DESIGN REVIEW:
Page lof2
2-11-5: DESIGN REVIEW:
(A) Review Of Permits: The HPC shall review and make recommendations to the City Council
concerning the issuance of City permits to do any of the following in relation to a property
designated as a Farmington heritage landmark:
1. Demolition of an historic building or structure.
2. Moving an historic building, structure, or object.
3. New construction of a principal building or accessory structure.
(B) Alterations: The HPC shall determine whether the proposed activity will alter, disturb,
deface or materially change the appearance or use of a heritage landmark. The HPC may
recommend to the City Council conditions for permit approval that it deems reasonable and
appropriate.
(C) Certificate Of Appropriateness: No permit will be issued by the City unless a certificate of
appropriateness has been granted by the HPC. A copy of the certificate of appropriateness
shall be attached to the permit when issued, and a copy filed with the City Building Official.
A certificate of appropriateness shall become void twenty four (24) months after issuance
unless a City permit has been issued.
(D) Development Projects: Every application for a preliminary or final plat, variance or
conditional use permit in relation to a significant historic property in the City shall be
reviewed by the HPC and their recommendation shall be forwarded to the Planning
Commission for consideration in making their recommendation to the City Council. In
determining whether or not a project will have an adverse effect upon a significant historic
property, the HPC shall consider the following factors:
1. Whether the development will substantially alter the appearance of an historic building,
site, structure, object or district so as to remove the features which distinguish the historic
property as a heritage landmark; and
2. Whether the use of the property will destroy, disturb or endanger a known or suspected
archeological feature.
(E) Design Review Standards And Guidelines: The Secretary of the Interior's standards for the
treatment of historic properties shall be the required basis for permit review decisions. The
City may adopt design review guidelines; in the absence of such guidelines, design review
decisions will be based upon the current Secretary of the Interior guidelines for
preservation, rehabilitation, restoration and reconstruction.
(F) Outside Technical Advice: The HPC may seek technical advice from outside its members
on any design review.
(G) Appeals: Any party aggrieved by a decision of the HPC shall, within ten (10) days of the
HPC's action approving or denying a certificate of appropriateness, have a right to appeal
such decision to the City Council. When denying a certificate of appropriateness, the HPC
shall advise the permit applicant of their right to file a written notice with the City
http://66.113.195.234/MN/Farmington/05011000000005000.htm
3/23/2006
2-11-5: DESIGN REVIEW:
Page 2 of2
Administrator requesting City Council review of the action taken by the HPC. Upon receipt of
the notice of appeal, the City Administrator shall transmit one copy to the HPC. (Ord. 099-
422,2-16-1999)
http://66.113.195.234/MN/Farmington/05011000000005000.htm
3/23/2006
#/e ry?':n~/~s
/a/t::>ft/
a. Historic Cemetery Preservation Guidelines - The Commission
discussed the following points in preparation for developing a preservation
plan:
. Boundaries of the cemetery should be clearly marked by the Developer
. A maintenance plan should be easy and simple to follow
. Clean-up could be performed by Girl Scouts and/or Boy Scouts
. Mowing should be done every 3rd year
. The Cemetery should contain native grasses
. If fenced it should be a vinyl coated black chain link or a pre-finished
white picket fence with a gate large enough to accommodate large
mowing equipment, lilacs or yews could be planted along the fence
line.
. If not fenced the corners could be marked with brick monuments and
lilacs or yews planted on the boundaries.
. An attempt should be made to recover all broken markers
. Consultant Vogel and an Archeologist on his staffwill help to
determine the number and locations of the grave sites and the
condition of the soils within the property.
. Donated trees or benches could be accepted for the property
. A marker should be placed identifying the cemetery and names of the
deceased
. Cemetery should be registered as a Farmington Heritage Landmark
b. Historic Site Markers and Plaques - Markers that would identify
properties designated as Heritage Landmarks. Discussion followed:
. Owner could determine whether plaque is placed inside or out
. Owner could pay 50%, City 50%
. A temporary sign could be placed in front yard bringing recognition to
the property
. Research possibility of placing in sidewalk area making it a permanent
marker to the property rather than placing it on the building
. Possibility of using pavers as the marker that could be incorporated in
the sidewalk system in the downtown
. A marker could be a stepping stone in residential areas
. A brochure could be created giving information on these properties
. Property owners could be included in planning the brochure
9. Miscellaneous - Next meeting of the HPC scheduled for January 10,2002.
10. Adjourn - Motion made and seconded to adjourn at 9:00 p.m.
~espectfullx submitted,
df{v~~~
Karen Finstuen
Administrative Services Manager
City of Farmington
325 Oak Street, Farmington, MN 55024
(651) 463-7111 Fax (651) 463-2591
www.ci.farmington.mn.us
TO:
Planning Commission
FROM:
Lee Smick, AICP
City Planner
SUBJECT:
Swanson Acres Preliminary Plat
DATE:
April 11, 2006
INTRODUCTION
Double E Development, LLC., has submitted a Preliminary Plat for the property located on the
west side of Akin Road and north of Middle Creek Estates, addressed as 20441 Akin Road
(Exhibit A). The developer is proposing 7 single-family lots in the R-1 Zoning District (Exhibit
B).
Plannine Division Review
Applicants:
Mark Emond
Jamie Elevestad
20534 Biscayne Avenue
Farmington, MN 55024
(612) 490-5100
Referral Comments:
1. City Engineering Division
2. Park & Recreation Division
Attachments:
1. Location Map
2. Narrative from Developer
3. Application for Preliminary Plat
4. Preliminary Plat
5. Preliminary Utility Plan
6. Preliminary Grading Plan
7. Existing Conditions
8. Detail Plan
Existing Conditions:
The existing site topography shows a 48-foot fall from the
west side of the property to the east side of the property,
creating an 11.8 % slope. The property is almost
completely wooded. An existing home currently resides on
the property; however, the developer proposes to demolish
the structure before construction begins. A demolition
permit will need to be applied for by the developer.
Proposed Development:
The developers propose to plat 7 single-family lots on 3.52
acres. The gross density proposed is 1.99 units/acre;
however, the net density proposed is 3.2 units/acre, thereby
meeting the Met Council's density requirements of 3 or
more units/acre.
Streets and Accesses:
The developers propose to construct a cul-de-sac to service
the lots. The cul-de-sac is proposed at approximately 253
feet in length and a 50-foot wide radius, meeting City
requirements. Access to and from the cul-de-sac will be
from Akin Road.
Water, Sanitary Sewer &
Storm Sewer:
A water main and sanitary sewer line currently exist on the
west side of Akin Road, providing readily available access
to these utilities. A storm water pond is proposed at the
north end of the site adjacent to Akin Road in order to
infiltrate surface water runoff from the existing drainage
ditch along the west side of Akin Road. An arched culvert
currently exists under Akin Road and will be utilized for
both surface water runoff and drainage from the pond. .
Sidewalks & Trails:
A trail currently exists on the east side of Akin Road.
There are no adjacent existing trails or sidewalks located on
the west side of Akin Road, therefore, the developers will
not be required to install these pedestrian ways
Wetland & Floodplain:
Wetlands or floodplains do not exist on the property.
Parkland:
The Parks & Recreation Director has determined that the
developers will be required to submit cash-in-lieu for park
dedication requirements because the development is less
that 5 acres in size and contains only seven lots.
DISCUSSION
The developers are proposing 7 single-family lots on 3.52 acres (153,378 square feet).
Excluding the pond (15,754 square feet) and arterial road right-of-way (Akin Road; 42,760
square feet) results in 94,864 net developable square feet or 2.18 net acres, resulting in a net
density of 3.2 units per acre. The 3.2 units/acre exceeds the Metropolitan Council's
requirements for densities at 3.0 units/acre and above.
2
Proposed Lot Sizes and Widths
The lot is located in the R-l Zoning District, which requires a minimum lot size of 10,000 square
feet and a minimum lot width of 75 feet. The lot sizes and widths are proposed as follows:
Lot
Lot 1
Lot 2
Lot 3
Lot 4
Lot 5
Lot 6
Lot 7
Lot Size
13,424 sf
17,820 sf
10,839 sf
16,594 sf
10,050 sf
10,004 sf
16,133 sf
Lot Widths
96 feet
75 feet
75 feet
76 feet
76.7 feet
75 feet
89 feet
All of the lots sizes and widths meet the minimum standards of the R-l Zoning District.
Proposed Housing
The proposed housing construction will include 1 full-basement, 1 full-basement with a walk-out
and the remaining 5 lots will be full-basement splits with look-outs.
Transportation
The preliminary plat shows 7 lots arranged around a 235-foot long cul-de-sac that will connect to
Akin Road. The cul-de-sac length meets the requirements of the City Code. The cul-de-sac
roadway width is proposed at 32 feet measured from face of curb to face of curb within a 60-foot
wide right-of-way. An 8% slope is proposed for the roadway at its highest point, leveling off at
the entrance to Akin Road at 2.9%. The developers are proposing a 60- foot wide radius to the
cul-de-sac, which meets City requirements.
Middle Creek Historic Cemetery - Heritage Landmark
As noted on the preliminary plat, the City of Farmington owns a cemetery at the southwest
comer of Swanson Acres. The Middle Creek Historic Cemetery was approved as a City
Landmark on February 18,2003. Per Section 2-11-5 of the City Code, the following is required:
D) Development Projects: Every application for a preliminary or final plat,
variance or conditional use permit in relation to a significant historic property in
the City shall be reviewed by the HPC and their recommendation shall be
forwarded to the Planning Commission for consideration in making their
recommendation to the City Council. In determining whether or not a project will
have an adverse effect upon a significant historic property, the HPC shall consider
the following factors:
1. Whether the development will substantially alter the appearance of an historic
building, site, structure, object or district so as to remove the features which
distinguish the historic property as a heritage landmark; and
3
2. Whether the use of the property will destroy, disturb or endanger a known or
suspected archeological feature.
The HPC should review the requirements of the City Code and determine if the "development will
substantially alter the appearance of an historic site".
Engineering Review
Retaining walls are proposed on the south and west property lines. The south walls are proposed
at heights up to 4 feet and the west walls are proposed at heights up to I 0 feet. An additional
retaining wall is proposed for the east side of Lot 1 at a height up to 1 0 feet. Any retaining wall
over 4 feet in height needs to be structurally engineered. Due to the grading cut into the slope for
house construction, the developer is proposing to install a chain link fence on the south and west
property lines adjacent to the retaining walls.
ACTION REQUESTED
Review comments from the Heritage Preservation Commission and make recommendations
concerning the approval of the Swanson Acres Preliminary Plat contingent upon any planning
and engineering requirements and forward the recommendation to the City Council.
Respe..ctS::ll bm??itted.. _
/Ab ./
ifC. ,",
Lee Smick, AICP
City Planner
cc: Double E Development, LLC.
File
4
,.."" Ham.:
\
\
>
I:P
- o~g
~ ~ ~II\
~~II\
!!l::D:II
~~z
"'. Q
~ - n
~ ~ ~~
i ~~
F ~i
~~
I
~~~ ~;~ ~~~ ,2 i!
-",--".,~~ I
~J) :~~ :~~ ~j ~i ~
I I I ~ 'Zz
--~ -..A: :...., )... ~a
. I" g3
~~
c ~
Ci.., 01
51
g ~
I'g
~~;
~=~
f:~
,~,
" ,
~
,.
I
lli
t1
'"
r
I
I
ill!l I
r~ 'il~~ C; I
= li~ -n
~ i ~ h r~j I
, ':il~~ ~:2
~ 11'1 '\/,
i ~hl
!~~.
~ ~~~
~ i~il
~ ~ 0
g
g I
CD 0
l:;j ~
i ~,...,
E!: '"
~; !2
z ~ ,..,
~~~
~" ;:::
~[l\~
~~
;! ~
~.~
g~ ~
~9 0
~B
I
\\\
\~ ./'t 't./ ./
'h, "/^v' / /~
[; \ V:y~ ~
J)~I L) 4:~ ',- /
~ ~ P i )//e::,././
. ]
./ ,.
~ ./(~! :~~ ~
r _ _~
~ )-~ ~;. ! ~
~ ','_"', ~;.. ~ e
~~
<::].> ~~
: ~ ~ C-_~ ~
~ !) !f
-- i
t~e
~q
~i~
~~
\
\
\
~'"
!.~~
~~~
He
UJ
~~
!Z~
UJ3
os'
ZQ
>'<
(')~
~Cl
l:I:J....
UJ
I
I
I!
~
I -
.,
.
:g I I ~
t1~t'
d:....
iT
n.c..~~
B' _._/
I .~.~ C:--'.d .
\~\ ~\
L \t=~~~
~-.-.
~
~
;;I
i!! ~
t~i ~ I~~ ~
~~ r- "I~ ::I
~~~ ~ ~ ii: 0
", C) ii: Ii {;J
;~~ ~ ~..~ ~
. ~ ~ ~~~ ~
n ~~ 0
^ . Z
~ !!i ..
lilt:
a~'
~d
~~;
m
!
~~~~~
~2~g~
~~~c"l
~i~~:
e~~;
~'L~
~~~~
~I;"~
e S'
~~~
~
~
~
.
~"
;~
~~
/"
/
i
~
n I ~!
i~i ~Ui I~i
:Ol!j s('l!2 ~!ll1'1
~?l ~~. h
6;5li!!!ai:..~
~~ ~ . ~ ~Ii~
!is t1 ~ . ?i
:.~ 11 5
iN .
~
is
r~ __.._,__,_'__'~~=m=- -1 />""
I ('\~- - - - - r ____ /' --/ ()~^
~ ~ ~g J -...... -I -::::-' (
~ ~ ~II\ I ,J'.')
i~z \
~~(j) I _-- I >-_-'\
in d I / ~~ \
~ i; ~ / ~~ \
~~ ~~i /
l!! .........
I ~ I ~
'" I
'" I
1----
I
)
--/-
~/ I
I
\ I
\ I
~ \\\
~ \ \ ,.,~,~,
\ ~"i ~ .rr'1D ~4'
~9 /' y..7.......
\?'b~, $"
,,~~4J /
/~" """ /'
,/' /'
./'
i
~
e
!:l
~
~
s
~ .lilll
i I : I
r~ '11'ji
! ; ~h
: 'I~~~
~ hdl
~ I
~ f;i ~
!: ~ rr1
~ e <:>
il; ~
Z!I1 r'1
;.~.-
Z Z 0
. "'-0
g ~ j!ii
~. ~
J)~I I
! ~ ~~ i
~
~
~
~
"'t:J
ooiil
~~
~ 5.
OOQ
0'<
Zc::
>~
(')~
=u
t":!:!;!
OOQ
::J
'l~
0) ~~I
'"
"'-
~
.......... ......................
~ !:'..,j !'- '-.. "-
I --- '-.. .'"',, "-
/ '-.." ,) ;j~' 'I. '-.. "-
/ '-.. ^, r
/ ) '-.. '-..
/ ) '-..
/ I
5
/
/'
OJ
\
\
\
\
\
\
~ a~ i
t iil; ~ i~ I
~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ f ~
~2~2~gg
~a~aa~ar
~~~~~~E8
~~~~~~~~
;z "0 ~ 1Il III ~ 0
~"ii~~~.
E~z~ ~
~ g "Q C) -< ~ VI
v, III 5 ~ ~ ~
~ !
~ ~
g
g~
8
g
~
~
1il
_3C~:il :.
0;
~
:il
--'
<(
I-
W
o
I
U
Z
w
CD
o
Z
o
0.
\
\
\
\
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~~~8 ;H~ 2
HH ~~U~~~
8882 6i!l~t:lb.~~3
~~~~ ~~Hn;~
~iO~~~ Ct:lS~~;~O
UJ~~~~ ~~19~~I=~~
~~8B8 BE~888~~
-'VlVlIllVl ~~~l!l~~~~
E~P ~~nn~",
~oo~ 0000055'"
11!IA1 !1[!I91l@jl,1!I
~ .".I~ ~ Hil i
1) ')") Cl i~ ~ ~'m 1
~ z; i~1 ~
I I 1 ~~ ",
j II ~
~ ~ ~~
~ lJl ~t!l
e ~ ;g
IS 0 Z~
n 5~
~ n5
~ ~ ~iil
>-
W
"
Z
o
F
<
I!:
Ul
~
~~tQ
~.
en ~
"
~ ffi~
\It ..CO
Oz
ZW
Ul il m ~~ c:
1m
C> ~ii tJ
z "'~ it rn
9 5~
5 h~ ~15 r:il
CD ~z 0113::
'" .S ()
~- "0<
~i e
>-", ~ ~Z
".: '"
,,>- ~ ~ ~~
;;!z
H N
~ tJ ~
.S
w .E
~ ~ ..::: rn
fl '" ~
~ ;~ ~ 0.:
'" :i~ ~ :i~
z ..
~ ~8S u'" F ~~
0 ~...JO
~ o::zt:j ~~~ "u
~ ffi -~
OJ 0 ~~i 0 ~h
~ '" ~~~
~ l:i~ ~O
w~ ~
fT1lf r
~
!i ~
~ ~ ~
"-,,, .
9 ~ ~
....~.
Gj .. ~
C ~~
w 2~
~ ~ ~
iii lD
~ is
f Cl
r-- ~l
h
....:.( 1;\
r-- l
r
r" a
,,>
~
~.Ly -
-/-
( ~~
L~J
...1-/ I 1,1
j~-_- " J" ~
w ",,, :I~ " u
~-................. ", ................. "
i--_ , ',I'
--1- " "1 '"
/ O$..~_-" ~ ") I ll.l "-
/ -/ ~ ~,\ \ I
00._ '\ l 1> . " " \ \ I __J
/ 3.tl...'OOS ./ f '\. i / .... "\ \ '-
, ro \ _~-~. I "" \ J '\ ~ -0,- ,_~
" .... / ( - '- / " \ ) .-/' -f
"'- \,,, :;z," _ 1\, ~ J - - _./ '71 ;
, --J"::- "" -, /I/F-/-' I ..-~--
-....... /' ..................... ........ '- l:o~'./ - I - - - ) I
'-. '-. '-.' "i r-)..-- - ,/ (0 -=t ,,--==' -'S~ cr / /-=,
'-. "" ,1, /" r ~ '-===-1-<--; / .--
'-. '1 /'. -.... .z..... ,[, I, \ - - I/'. ,:;:~
............ '~,~I,! ~S'~:"~lf ,~1..... ,..,....,~ - - - J /
'-. '.: l~':; '- / -:' ) _ (}-:. L /' - / ~ t!
........... ~~ ~ I l' I I (_) /..... .............. ... I
-.......... "- C:' / "c=, ./ ........... . I /
........... 'v' .<'/ /"- "I I
~ <,,// I / /
......... '-"1(1ftI:}_\.lIMl:l\~_\~I~.;I--
.,/
/"
il: II,!
h.l. .
51-1~ <J
hil~
wI'
~l
g i!:
i ~
iil
n
;i
~
!
,.
~
v!
~S
C> .
Z>!
c:i
WG..~
ww~
cD~ 0 ~
OC>VJ
eX..
~
---;;-
./
./
./
./
./
--
/"
/"
~ ~ ~
d ~~~~a ~
... <( l!? ~ >- CI ~ ~
q~a~~~~ ~
r;s~~~<~~m CI
~ Z :l: III ~ '" !i!i ~
~~~q~~u ~
w~~~W~B5B
8~8~~~~n ~
-'~~~~550~ ~
Lni5~~o
~ e 500 j
I: <:>t@19~
H : %~ 'IWI
I I 2C11 :::
I I I ~~ iiliJ
I ,
I ,
'"
"'
'"
II
en
r.:I
p::
U
<
~
o
E-<
Yr\
- I
iig~ I
8~~j
~~~!i
...11110.1:>
~~~8
~oo
OJ:!
j::::~
-t.)
~<
8z
o
~rIl
~~
~~
GSrIl
t,
'i<
~~
'" I a~
~ 11 :5l
~
,
i
:;
~
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
!l!1
~I
;\
~ I /'
~I
r/
/1
/' .
/(.
/'
/'
/'
/'
~A
~ .~
~ ~~
9 ~ ~
~ ~ .
w ~~
~ ~i
~N,,-
lD
=>
o
'"
/
/'
/'
/'
/'
/'
/'
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
o :~~
I
s~
h
~i5
i~
~
i
"
,c)
,t</
.."
"-
, ,
t....,'
/"
~
. ~
~ti
-~
C> . ~
Z~!
-z~
:g:~
\11 \11 ~ ~
C!:l~o _
oC>vJ
a:..
~
/
/
<
'\
\
r::;p
~ ~~g
~ ~ tI\ tI\
~:3>>tI\
-z:3>>
;-cZ
~ __ (i)
;~ d
l! ~~
~ i!2
~ ~I
~ ~..
; I
\~
"_IJ:\__,-~'~\_\IoI<wU'\ptrAU'\<<1'~_
z
~
e e rns
!)Hf-'~:~
~ ,g : c;
!~:.~! eJ
i~ i; . I " I~
H. f-L-j;;
Q~ C ..,'
~il :t~
!f~ ~~
:;0 ~o~
!'.[ e
~ !6~
9- ig
"z
",/2'5
"
BIZ.. S"/
~li~ >~ . ..... ~.t 1" :.
s " ~~. '6 ~ ~
. 1- ~ ~
W f-2:-j ~ .
"
"
o
~
!'
~~~
000
~SSl
m"H"
~;~
0 )
0 ~
c i
CD
~ N f;j ~ m ~
I~ ~ C) 12:;;:i1
~ 10
",.0 II ;:J ~'ll, I ,I
H~ z .Hth if
., ()
~~~ () ~. '" .~
11 I ;i
0 :e nm;
g ~ fii z -f 0 is'
Ul t. 0
NeZ ;;j ~ 0 ! ll!t~ ~i
.......,;-1 c i1, I.
~ .
F f, 'i~ i llf
0 q.
n z ~~. f i[ i' .......
~ ~ I: r:. .::: .
,:,~ ~ ..:., ',',
f t. l' S
. ~ . I z l{ ;:~ '
8 ~ ~ () - t
'" r
l
~~
(/}~
OQ
z=::::
>~
og
~
I?'J
(/}
l~
O)~
:;!
;0
;::
Z
Cl
-i
o
Z
I;
;::
Z
z
'"
'"
o
-i
)>
'!i 9rnJl
b J g~
- I "!
l~
~Q
~'n
i!
."
)>
::0
:;;::
~ ~~I
z ~ '"
~~
;:: ;oc!
m~
~ ~~ ~
~ ~~ua~
:; ii:~i{"
~1l11~ 1m
~w ~1-
ai'i.. ~~ !lH ..i~
.!.:'a !!J! li' l~ . ...;. a lor'
~- ~"~.!l !.i "!.}i1
~q
~~: > >
..
illMf
!!.~ i~ g'! !f
...;: 5"
po R":-J po po f>
g~ ~~ I!l~~ ~~ ~~
~ c;;l o"R ii:~ "l~
~~ =i~ ~311l i!!~ ;ij~
~~ <!i "3~ ~" ~~
~l ~g i~~ ~~ ~~
;;l~ '"'~ ~~c ~~ ">1
~~ ~~ i~~ :<~ t'li
T~ ..,. a" ~ ~
s~ ~~ . ~~ ; ~
a ~ ~i!i~ ~
~::j ;;I;""
~~ ~~!il
ae ,
~G 9
iO
is-~;1
~~~ g
~~.~~
, _. ~ 0
~!~;
~'.
~S;:
-~ Q
[] ~
~ 0 0
~(IIe.
.-
~l~
~3::
iti
~ii
:~!.
~ [~
-:::-o~
~o::
o~::
~~~
;2.0
o 9"
1: ~
~ ~2.
~ ~
~
~ :
91 !II !" ~ '"
~~I!l !~I!l m ~~~ 1il~1!l ~mi
r;;lo )OiOIo F~O f;;lo ~~o In 8;;lo
~~ S<i1~ ~~ i1~ ?<i1~ jl ;liI~
_"I<l~" .!.~ 1." ~.!... !I:!:lb"
i~~i~ i~ i~~;~~~i~
2111:! Z ~6c~:a:F I
~~ !~ ~~ ~~ ~jl~ i 2~
~ }:fII }:fII r:::fII :;:fII"V ~In 8
?;~ ~i ~i ...~ ""i z ~i z
go >c ~c 2~ io ~ c en
,,~ ~~ ill~ ill~ I~ ill ~~ :;l
~~ C;D~ ~c C gC 5
~ ~ ~r:"V~ ~ iB~ 5
z
z
o
PI
'"
~ ~:""
~~~ :,~ ~ii:~i~~ iQ~~
Pi :( g~~~:i!C;D% c!i1t"l~
:;;8~ ~~i;;lm~~~ ~~~
>>~ m~O<'" o;'I:z Q!!
!ile~ ~Fii:~~~a~ ~a;~
nllr~ ;;l~ ;li'"O~ r-O~
~C;l < e ~li~~. ~~..~
~~li ~~jlI~\'I~~~ ~"d
:i~ ~~1Il~~~: ~~;;j~ 0
~ e:iai~~~ !:il~~~ ~
N.t"l-i.' bQjt. bt;'lt:lt"l ~
~ ~ -~s:""~ ~
o
::l
~
z
o
PI
!(l
:: !" P' ;-l
! ~ ~~~~~~i j~~ ?; ~ ~~~
2 iI >uiSi!eit"lz J:;_Z :i! fII O::1~
g~ ~~ "'~~: E:~ ~i :tClfll
~i ~ ~~~~~ ..~~ ~5 ~2~
a!2 ~~~gfllz~ ~g~ 2 ~~i
; ~ ~a::~g~ z~: i ~ ~~~~
~ 3 a ~Q~ ~2"" "" ""~
~ ~ c~~~:l 2~~ iI m~
; i~a:i!~~ ~~a b a-i~
!i :~~m ~h ~ ~~~
." i~51U; ,..~~ Ii!: ~
~ an!il~zF ~a ~ ~ ~
~ li~S 11\ ~e "g ~
S fII ~ ~
a r ~
~
o
~
z
<:l
~
o
U>
~
~
~.
e.
,
'"
e. is
, c:
m III
~ '"
~
Gl
~
s
.--
8
'"
z
0
nil :un
i ~ ~ ~ ~
\
~ I -0
0
Z
0
II)
.-- -c r'1
\ 0
~ z Z
0 ()
<II \1; il <II I
'"
z .., 0
n z
:I: () rr1
Z :I: -<
~
c:> 0 r=
~- ~
\ .--
\
\
? !D
'"
Cf~~~~3:
~ ~c~ 0 a.a
~~~~~~3:
&.'< =r ~ (II
~[~ ~ ~J
a!!~;~g
~!~ ~ ~i
.g 3.0 Iii ~~
~~~ 2. ~g
o ::) N....Q.
g~'fI 0;:=
"' 3 ~~ (II ~
;~~~ Ii
:] g ~ ~ i
~~g~~~
2 = (II 0 (II
~[3 ~ Ita:
~HH~
;!!i % ~ ~
~~s.~ ~s
1II;;:<D &.~ t.>
o;~O'~~
~ 53 ~ Q 3
aSS~:~
~!i};~;;
:; 5 g,...~
2;r,;; g ~~
2. ~ .g.~
0"
00
, ,
~!
~"
[~
fl~
[~
s-~
~a
~:r
3.~
(II ~ ~
o 00
{T ~ ~a
;' -
; ~ : ~
s= ~ [g
~ : i~
"f g~
r_ t ~.~
[ ~.~
. . ~
&. ~ [i
: to !!.....
8. ':< g
i~' ~
i~ g
i~ [
!l '0:5- !i
~
[ ~
I
i I
[ :7
o
~
i
~
g;
"
'"
;l~i ~
g:r~ ~~
~~~ ~3
[~2rr~
f~~[:
gSsl!
[Ii;:'
l!;Jr
8.~i~:~'
.g a.~.o a.
g,O'(j go
:~3~~
!!._C::T~
g 3~!!l g
Q=2.:;~g.
HU;
;~;i~
!!gS:_~
!!l2, gO (II
~J-g[li
i~~; i
&itgo.gg
gg:E~~
0.-: ~a~
!.~ 2~:r
~ III ~~
>1;
00
~~
0"
gW'
o~
~~
~r[
H
0,
"~
. .
o~
~:
~~
~ ~
~~
:rg-
aii-
l[
00
,-
~-
3;
i[
~2.
~.
070
~..
~i
g ,.
~;
~':<
~ ~ ~
'"
~ ~ ~
: f I
. !f
g:;~ g-g;:
g~1 ;~: (")
~~.~ ~ [~. ~
[~&: !!g'~ ~
; ltI!i!li i
Do 0"~3"";-no VI
~ ~Q.i~g~~
~ ~Ui~i~
; !i'~:~~.[3
: l~~';~~~
D. g;~~2.i2.
i g n
~;~Hii
~~i:.[~J
&i~~gg~
~~nni
~~1fQ.~!~
=~
o w.
l~
,0
-0
g,{
-"
o.
00
o
~
'TJ' 0' 0
[
~ g g
o <r
n n 3
; I ~
~. VI
0:
~
la ~
~. ~
.go. ~
~
! ~
~ ~
2: ~.
~ ~
a ,
~ '<
o
~
~
j.
<;
Uco
~<o1.
;!
~
z
'i
i
i
n '.i t.!
I~J ~ i i : i J
.' I ~ [1' { ; 1 :
!lll J J d H L I
,I ['~~'.i.'
i~i . Ii!;. rq 1
.~, I j j .., I ) I .
'~. ~:! ~ . 1! J i~ 1
'n , , · . 'I . i " !
Iii i I ! H I ~ ~; H ~
lji [; t i ~!: i i {i i
Oi !~!q i j j H ~! H !i I
I" hI' < ! ;,. '1 H; . ;. ;
'i! ." J i . 1 i' ~ I '. , . .. I
Cl ~:5li ~ : i I 'i 11 It ~ ~ .:1 .
~ I't, I ; !. f 1 !li .! h ~
~ Aid. I . A .
~
iJ
-~
_.~::...:;..,
t::
~
a.:rn
<bl!cl
g.~
oU
~<
6Z
-.10
0rn
.~ ~
.~ rn
~
Q..
g
i3
z
z
:i
~
z
Ii !l1 ~
~ oc~
a. w .
o 5 ~
~~i
O~:i
w 2 ~
l!i w
" -'
S lD
I g
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
---
I ~
Ii I
ilit ~
n ~!
8 _ ~
\!) '5
~~!
~lE~
~~~ ~
O\!)VJ
cL
/
/
/
'-<"
"
/
\ ~~ /
\ ~~ /
:v--<
I \
) J-"
./
"" / ~
'-V
/
I /
/ /
",,~ /
'- '- '- '- '-<(
"'-....
'-....~
r
--~
'-
-~..-....
-,-
--
7e
City of Farmington
325 Oak Street, Farmington, MN 55024
(651) 463-7111 Fax (651) 463-2591
www.ciJarmington.mn.us
TO:
Mayor, Councilmembers, City Administrator ~
Lisa Shadick, Administrative Services Director
FROM:
,
SUBJECT:
Middle Creek Historic Cemetery Project
DATE:
November 15,2004
INTRODUCTION
At the November 4, 2004 Heritage Preservation Commission meeting, the Commission approved
a project to improve the trail to the Middle Creek Historic Cemetery.
DISCUSSION
Mr. Billy Samuelson from Farmington Boy Scout Troop #119 presented an Eagle Scout project
summary and outline for the Middle Creek Historic Cemetery.
The project would identify the trail entrance and clear the path to the cemetery. The path
currently has fallen trees and overgrown brush making the trail difficult to navigate. The boy
scouts will open up the trail by removing the brush and fallen branches. City staff will remove
barbed wire fencing that crosses the path and cut up the fallen trees into manageable pieces.
Directional signs will also be placed to help guide visitors to the cemetery. Mr. Samuelson will
be the leader on this project and will work with other scouts and parent leaders.
Attached is the project summary outlining the trail restoration of the Middle Creek Historic
Cemetery.
BUDGET IMPACT
Any funding required will be done by fundraising efforts of Mr. Billy Samuelson and Troop 119.
ACTION REQUIRED
Approve the trail restoration project of the Middle Creek Historic Cemetery by Troop 119.
Respectfully submitted,
~d.AIL~
Lisa Shadick
Administrative Services Director
Boy Scout Eagle Scout Project
Middle Creek Historic Cemetery
In the City of Farmington, MN.
By Billy Samuelson
Life Scout
Troop 119
Scoutmaster: Jim Harper
November 2004
Billy Samuelson
18414 Eldorado Way
Farmington, MN 55024
651-463-4678
Boy Scout Eagle Scout Project
Middle Creek Historic Cemetery
In the City of Farmington, MN.
Table of Contents
Project Summary.. . . .. . .. .. . . .. . .. .. . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. . .. . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . .. . .... .. . . . . . . . . ..1
Proj ect Outline. .. . .. .. _ .. .. .. . .. . .. .. . . .. . . _ .. . .. . .. . . .. .. . .. . .. . .. . .. .. .. .. .. .. . .. . . . .. .. .. .. . . . . . . .2
Pictures............................................................................................. ....4
E-mail from Randy Distad. .. .... ..... . ............ .. .. .. ..... ., . _' .., . ... .. -., .. . .. .. -. . -.. .. .. . ...5
Map. .. .. . .. . . . . . . . .. . .. .. . . . . . . . .. ... . .. . . . .. . . . .. . . .. .. . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . .. . . . . .. .. . . ..... . . .. .. . .. . .. ..6
Project Summery
Objective I
My plan is to have a clearly identifiable entrance, along with proper and
appropriate signage. This would convey to visitors that they are on city property and
should respect the area.
Objective n
Doing some restoration work on the head stones would help preserve them
currently there are several which are in a state of disrepair.
1
Project Outline
Entrance & Trail
. Clearly identify the trail head.
. Open up the trail head entrance_ Maybe install a split rail fence.
. Clear the existing path of fallen & dead trees.
. Remove wire fence from fence posts and discard.
. Provide direction signs* at entrance & at trail fork.
*Design, placement, cost and installation to be provided by park district.
Cemetery Plat
. Repair & straighten fallen head stones. Cement in and clean up.
. Install a park bench. * (suggested by Randy Distad) See E-mail attachment
*Design, placement, cost and installation to be provided by park district
. Install a park history plague outlining the cemetery name and dates. * (Approved
by H.P.C.)
Possible signs
. No Dumping
. City Property
. Nature area
. Park hours
. Name Middle Creek Historic Cemetery .
. No loitering
. No motorized vehicles
Tools that I will need to obtain
. Rakes
. Shovels
. Wheel barrows
. Post hole digger
. Wire cutters*
. Chain saw*
. Pruning sheers
. Hanuners
. Safety glasses
Most of the item I can ask for the scouts to bring from there home the day of the
project. The ones with the * I might have trouble getting.
2
Workers
. My main source of labor will be Boy Scouts and parent leaders.
Funding
. Seek donations form different sources.
. Troop fundraising.
. Local area civic groups.
. Local area businesses.
Concerns I have
. What I should do the old wire fence after it is taken out?
. What to do with the fallen trees; push to the side or log it out?
. Can the fence posts be left in the ground because they are not in the way?
Safety
. There will be a number of adults who are trained for first aid if an accident were
to occur.
. I know first aid, and we will always have a cell phone & a first aid kit on site.
Some general notes & comments
. I will be contacting the Natural Resources Specialist to identify the fallen tree
types. Maybe some one would cut the tree up in exchange for the wood? Would
insurance be an issue?
. I would like to start now and work on and off on it till the snow covers come then
complete the project in the spring.
3
I was thinking that I could maybe do
something to accent the trailhead a
little more. Make it more visible to the
public.
I want to
rejoin this
fallen
tombstone and
recast it in
concrete..
4
subject: . RE: Eagle Scout Project Farmington Cemetery
Date:
Fri, 29 Oct 2004 09:56:31 -0500
. from:
"Randy Distad" <rcIistad@CI.FARMINGTON.MN.US>
To:
"Billy Samuelson" <speedracer2106@yahoo.com>
cc:
"Lisa Shadick" <lshadick@Cl.FARMINGTON.MN.US>
Billy,
I would also like to suggest that you contact Lisa Shadick who is the staff liaison to the Heritage
Preservation Commission for her ideas. Lisa has been involved with improving the cemetery for
several years now. I know that there was a landscape improvement plan developed that Lisa
could provide more information to you about. While I am not an expert about what might be
allowed in the cemetery, I would defer that to Lisa regarding what is or isn't allowed, t do have
some ideas that might work. It might be nice to have a few heavy duty and sturdy benches near
the cemetery where people could sit. A wood chip or crushed limestone path might be nice
leading people up to the cemetery. Perhaps a sign would be nice identifying the cemetery.
Some of the brush and broken branches could be cleaned up and removed from the site. These
are just some of my thoughts. Again I think it is best if you work with Lisa on what is or isn't
allowed for improvement projects in the cemetery.
Randy Distad, CPRP
Parks and Recreation Director
City of Farmington
phone: (651) 463-1851 fax: (651) 463-2591
A parks and recreation director who likes to work at play and play at1Vork!
-----Original Message-----
From: Billy Samuelson [mailto:speedracer2106@yahoo.com]
sent: Thursday, October 28,20047:11 PM
To: Randy Distad
Subject: Eagle Scout Project Farmington Cemetery
Dear Mr. Distad,
My name is William Samuelson. I am a sophomore at FHS. I am also
a Life Scout doing an Eagle Scout project in conjunction with the City
of Farmington Heritage Preservation Committee as well as the Parks and
Rec. Dept. My father Edgar Samuelson is currently on the Heritage
Preservation Commission. I am preparing my report for the groups and would
like to solicit your input. I would be curious if you would make some
recommendations for the old cemetery on Eaves Way.
5
Parking
--.
'"
i
Possible
direction sign
Eaves Way
A recognizable
station of some
sort
Tree Line
Possible sign
Readable head
stone. Just tipped
over
6
Shrub Line
00 0
.6 Head
~ stone
"\ bases
with
broken
; stone
around
the area
~Y:
--1?6-
City of Farmington
325 Oak Street, Farmington, MN 55024
(651) 463-7111 Fax (651) 463-2591
www.ci.farmington.mn.us
TO:
Mayor, Councilmembers and City Administrator~'"
FROM:
Lisa Shadick, Administrative Services Director
SUBJECT:
Consider Resolution - Designating Farmington Heritage Landmark
DATE:
February 18, 2003
INTRODUCTION
The City Council may designate individual historic sites as Farmington Heritage Landmarks.
DISCUSSION
The Heritage Preservation Commission has determined that the Middle Creek Historic Cemetery,
located north of the Middle Creek Estates subdivision, meets the eligibility criteria for
designation as a Farmington Heritage Landmark under City Code 2-11-4(A). The HPC has
submitted documentation supporting the Heritage Landmark designation of the Middle Creek
Historic Cemetery in a report prepared by Robert Vogel dated September 26, 2002. The
Minnesota Historical Society has also commented favorably on the proposed landmark
designation.
BUDGET IMP ACT
None.
ACTION REQUESTED
Adopt a resolution designating the Middle Creek Historic Cemetery, as a Farmington Heritage
Landmark, and noting the Middle Creek Historic Cemetery as a heritage landmark on the
Official City Zoning Map.
Respectfully submitted,
~/l.Jha~
Lisa Shadick
Administrative Services Director
cc: HPC Members
Robert Vogel
.;;l30
RESOLUTION NO. R -03
DESIGNATING THE MIDDLE CREEK HISTORIC CEMETERY
AS A FARMINGTON HERITAGE LANDMARK
Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of
Farmington, Minnesota, was held in the Council Chambers of said City on the 18th day of
February 2003 at 7:00 p.m.
Members Present:
Members Absent:
Member
introduced and Member
seconded the following:
WHEREAS, the Farmington City Council has declared as a matter of public policy that the
preservation, protection, perpetuation, and use of significant historic properties is a matter of
public necessity; and,
WHEREAS, the Heritage Preservation Commission has determined that the Middle Creek
Historic Cemetery, meets the eligibility criteria for designation as a Farmington Heritage
Landmark under City Code 2-11-4(A); and,
WHEREAS, the Heritage Preservation Commission has submitted documentation supporting
Heritage Landmark designation of the Middle Creek Historic Cemetery in a report prepared by
Robert C. Vogel, Preservation Planning Consultant, dated September 26, 2002; and,
WHEREAS, the Minnesota Historical Society has commented favorably on the proposed
landmark designation; and,
WHEREAS, a public hearing on the proposed landmark designation was held in the City
Council Chambers in City Hall on February 18, 2003.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that:
1. The Middle Creek Historic Cemetery is designated as a Farmington Heritage Landmark.
2. The Middle Creek Historic Cemetery will be noted as a heritage landmark on the Official
City Zoning Map.
This resolution adopted by recorded vote of the Farmington City Council in open session on the
18th day of February 2003.
Mayor
Attested to the
day of
2003.
City Administrator
SEAL
~~J
Robert C. Vogel & Associates
Historians, Archeologists and Preservation Planners
216 Cleveland Avenue S.W.
New Brighton, Minnesota 55112-3508
Telephone (651) 604-0175
Fax (651) 604-0250
MEMORANDUM
8 January 2003
*: L. Shadicl{, Administrative Services Director
FR' obert Vogel, Preservation Planning Consultant
. Farmington Heritage Landmark Designation of Middle Creek Cemetery
The City is ready to proceed with Heritage Landmark designation of the Middle Creek
Cemetery. The Heritage Preservation Commission has already nominated the property
based on my report of 26 September 2002. The Minnesota Historical Society has been
given an opportunity to comment on the nomination as provided in Minn. Stat. ~471.193.
By ordinance (~2-11-4C), the City Council may designate a Farmington Heritage
Landmark by resolution, after holding a public hearing. Public hearing notices must be
published 10 days prior to the meeting and written notice must be mailed to "all owners
of property lying adjacent to the historic property." Because the City of Farmington
owns the cemetery, historic site owner notification is not necessary.
I have attached the final draft copy of the nomination documents.
Cultural resource management consultants since 1978.
~.3~
DOCUMENTATION SUPPORTING HERITAGE LANDMARK
DESIGNATION OF THE MIDDLE CREEK HISTORIC CEMETERY
COMMONLY KNOWN AS THE PRESBYTERIAN CEMETERY
Heritage Landmark Planning Report
Prepared by Robert C. Vogel
Preservation Planning Consultant
September 26, 2002
INTRODUCTION
This report documents the historical and architectural significance of the Middle
Creek Historic Cemetery, commonly known as the Presbyterian Cemetery and makes the
case for the property's eligibility for designation as a Fannington Heritage Landmark
pursuant to ~2-11-4 of the Farmington City Code.
Farmington Heritage Landmarks are the buildings, sites, and districts so
designated by the City Council in recognition of their historical, architectural,
archeological, and cultural significance. Properties are nominated by Heritage Landmark
designation by the Heritage Preservation Commission (HPC) following a public hearing.
Under state law, the Minnesota Historical Society must also review each nomination.
Once a property has been designated a Fannington Heritage Landmark, this report
becomes part of the official designation and is used to guide planning for the
preservation, protection, and use of the historic property.
The Heritage Landmark Planning Report is based on the National Register of
Historic Places Registration Form. For more information about registration standards and
guidelines for preparing the report, please refer to the National Park Service publication,
How to Complete the National Register Registration Form; and the Historic Preservation
chapter of the City of Farmington Comprehensive Plan.
ADMINISTRATIVE DATA
Name of Property: The official name of the property nominated for landmark
designation is the Middle Creek Historic Cemetery. The site is also commonly known as
the Presbyterian Cemetery.
Location: Southeast quarter of Section 25, Township 114 North Range 20 West,
immediately north of the Middle Creek Estates subdivision.
Owner: On December 17, 2001, the Farmington City Council accepted the
cemetery from the First United Presbyterian Church, the owner of record (Resolution
R114-01).
0733
HPC Determination of Eligibility: The Farmington Heritage Preservation
Commission evaluated the cemetery and found that it meets the criteria for heritage
landmark eligibility. A finding of significance was issued by the HPC on December 6,
2001.
State Historic Preservation Office Review: In accordance with Minnesota Statutes
9471.193, the Minnesota Historical Society will be sent a copy of this report for review
and comment before the nomination is heard by the Farmington City Council.
Classification: For preservation planning purposes, the property is considered a
historic site.
Historic and Current Function/Use: Historically, the site was used as a cemetery.
It currently functions as open space.
DESCRIPTION
Site Classification: Abandoned rural cemetery.
Boundaries: The boundaries of the heritage landmark are those of the parcel
historically associated with the cemetery.
Narrative Description:
The historic cemetery is situated on the summit of low, wooded hill (elev. 956 ft.
above sea level) near the intersection of Akin Road and Eve's Way, immediately north of
the Middle Creek Estates Subdivision. The burial ground encompasses a rectangular
shaped parcel measuring approximately 264 by 165 ft. and oriented east-west.
Historically, the site was unplatted but removed from routine farming activities. It was in
use until the early twentieth century, when it was abandoned and fell into neglect. It does
not appear to have been enclosed with any kind of fence. The traditional nineteenth
century graveyard ornamental trees, such as pines or cedars, are absent and there is no
evidence of any hedgerows, shrubbery, or grave plantings. Near the center of the historic
site there is a small open area with a cluster of stone grave makers and scattered
fragments of broken gravestones. The largest of these is a marble tablet inscribed in low
relief with the names of Charles Seward, S. Anderson, and Caroline Seward. The other
stones and stone fragments lack readable inscriptions. The is evidence of an old trail or
lane leading to the cemetery from Akin Road, but at present public access to the site is
over a pedestrian trail from the city's Pine Knoll lift station.
Information about the persons interred at the cemetery is sketchy. According to
the 1881 narrative history of Dakota County, the first burial, that of Ada Bacon, occurred
in 1859, and in June, 1868, the plot of land was donated by Samuel Osborne to the
Trustees of the Farmington Presbyterian Church for use as a cemetery. Charles Seward's
obituary in the March 8, 1901, issue of the Dakota County Tribune, notes that he was
2
d31/
buried in the "old cemetery in Judson's Grove." The obituary written for his wife, Jane
Osborne Seward, printed in the Tribune on November 13, 1903, states that she was
"interred in the Presbyterian cemetery" alongside her husband and two of their children.
The cemetery is located on the map of Farmington published in 1896 but it does not
appear on any modem topographical or street map. Local genealogists have documented
at least twenty-four burials, including several members of the Seward and Witherell
families, and suggest that the cemetery was no longer used after about 1906. The site is
visible as a clearing surrounded by farmland on an aerial photograph flown in 1937 and
the cemetery is noted on the Farmington Quadrangle USGS topographic map published
in 1974. A grave robber is purported to have disturbed at least one grave in 1980.
Except for occasional notice in local newspapers and a brief article in the county
historical society's newsletter, the cemetery was largely forgotten until 2001, when
Arcon Development and D. R. Horton proposed to build a residential subdivision called
Middle Creek Estates on a 40.74 acre parcel west of Akin Road. The abandoned
cemetery appeared on the site plan as an unregistered parcel of vacant land adjacent to
the north boundary of the subdivision. The Heritage Preservation Commission reviewed
the Middle Creek Estates preliminary plat application and on October 18, 2001,
recommended that the developer survey the cemetery, stake the boundaries, and fence the
site as a condition of plat approval. When the Council approved the preliminary plat on
December 17, 2001, a contingency of approval stated that the developer had to "re-survey
the cemetery site to ensure no additional markers lie outside the property and to identify
the property comers."
EVALUATION
Applicable Heritage Landmark Criteria: The Middle Creek Cemetery is eligible
for Heritage Landmark designation because of its documented association with specific
patterns of events which have made a significant contribution to Farmington history (City
Code ~2-11-4A).
Local Historic Context: The property was evaluated within the local historic
context, "Churches and Cemeteries," as delineated in the 1995 historic context study.
Area of Significance: Social history.
Period of Significance: 1859 to ca. 1906.
Narrative Statement of Significance:
The Middle Creek Cemetery is a vernacular landscape site that was used as a
burial ground by residents of Farmington between 1859 and ca. 1906. Evaluated within
the local historic context "Churches and Cemeteries," it is historically significant for its
association with the First Presbyterian Church (est. 1865) and the broad pattern of
nineteenth century cultural values and funerary practices in rural Farmington. The site is
distinguishable from its surroundings by the presence of gravestones and shallow
depressions in the surface of the ground which are interpreted as graves. Its historic
3
"-:~~l
.;(35
function as a cemetery has also influenced the character and composition of surrounding
development, both agricultural (1850s through 1960s) and suburban (1970s to the
present).
The Middle Creek Cemetery is a representative example of the small burial
grounds which are scattered across Minnesota's rural landscape. As a cultural relic, the
site represents a distinctive folk tradition and helps to tell the stories of the area's earliest
settlers and their rural way of life. The rural setting is evocative of the early period of
settlement and the surviving gravemarker is typical of the period. Interwoven with the
site's landscape history are the lives of the individuals who are buried there.
Heritage landmark designation is only a step in the preservation of the historic
site, which should be reclaimed for public use as conservancy open space. The Heritage
Preservation Commission has recommended that the burial ground be marked with four
freestanding masonry columns or obelisks, set approximately 100 ft. apart. The comers
should also be staked. Signs and markers would be helpful in informing visitors of the
site's historical significance and natural heritage. It should not be necessary to reset fallen
gravestones or replace lost monuments with new markers, though it is recommended that
the city remove all fallen tree branches, buckthorn, and other undesirable plant material.
Routine pruning of trees and shrubs, weeding, and mowing are the keys to historic site
maintenance and the natural beauty of the site could be enhanced through appropriate
landscaping. Well maintained site and appropriate interpretation will demonstrate the
city's commitment to preserving a respectable environment for public use. The Secretary
of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties are the required basis
for historic site preservation and rehabilitation work, and the National Park Service has
also issued guidelines for the treatment of cultural landscapes which are applicable to
historic cemeteries.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
"The Abandoned Cemetery of Farmington Village." Over the Years vol. 32 (Winter
1992).
Agricultural Adjustment Administration. Dakota County, Minnesota, aerial survey
photographs, 1937. Borchert Map Library, University of Minnesota.
Birnbaum, Charles A., and Christine Capella Peters. The Secretary of the Interior's
Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties with Guidelines for the Treatment
of Cultural Landscapes. Washington: U.S. Department of the Interior, National Park
Service, 1996.
History of Dakota County and the City of Hastings, Including the Explorers and Pioneers
of Minnesota, by Rev. Edward D. Neill, and Outlines of the History of Minnesota, by
J. Fletcher Williams. Minneapolis: North Star Pub. Co., 1881.
4
~3~
Pinkney, B. F. Plat Book of Dakota County, Minnesota. Philadelphia: Union Publishing
Co., 1896.
Potter, Elizabeth Walton and Beth M. Boland. Guidelines for Evaluating and Registering
Cemeteries and Burial Places. National Register Bulletin 41. Washington: U.S.
Department of the Interior, National Park Service, 1992.
Sloan, David Charles. The Last Great Necessity: Cemeteries in American History.
Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1991.
Vogel, Robert C. Farmington Historic Context Document: Final Report of the Historic
Context Study, 1994-1995. Unpublished report prepared for the Farmington Heritage
Preservation Commission, July, 1995.
ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION
1. USGS Farmington Quadrangle topographic map.
2. Middle Creek Estates site plan.
3. Photographs of historic site.
5
c:? 3 :>
1. USGS Farmington Quadrangle topographic map
6
c93ca-
--
_~.ec.
__"\Cl.U1lJl5O
---
~.=
~~~".I.
flf1MJ'/IDr;!t __
, ft
I
~
SETBACKS
_..-.,.
__n
_,n
_'n
!IlItPlUf2Dn
.."_.>>"S1IIU:Ili~
~~~~1.~.;:;
~.":.:.='::-=:':'''':
-..---...---
..-..----....---
==:;:5:.==.0::.::;;;.....-":'".::;:'..
..--.......------
-....-..--
t~
.... .
2. Middle Creek Estates site plan
MIDDLE CREEK ESTATES
PRELIMINARY PLANS
FARMINGTON, MINNESOTA
",.'
!
I.
\
, /
( /
i i
( \
\ \.
\ \. -.:_UIt
\\\'\\
,/----' j
// ,.-_..//
, , \...~
I
1
_##..##-
" /"",:: l___,_ -. """"a
''- ' I ( , ,
: C__>/~eg----:\ \ "'I'
.... ,~.. I
----- --- \ .
~ / ~..:--....
\
\,
,/
\
/.
-
.--
--.
--
-~-
...-;'
or _ =~5.:'?E.-==';':"-;:':=
CO\IER SHEET - SIlt PlAN
-ARCON OEVElOPMENT. INC.
- WlDOl..E CREOC ESTA'IES
7
SHEET INDEX
1. COVER SHEET - S1lE PLAN
2. PRWMINARY PlAT
3. EXISl1NG CONDll1ONS
4. PRWMINARY GRAlllNG PLAN
S. PREUMINARY Ul1UTY PLAN
6. PREUMINARY LANDSCAPE PlAN
7. DETAIlS
-!. -1.'-
-A. ~_.......
___ ___co..._
_......o-.__~
__ -0-.__
-.___--1-
!!! ~:=:::L-
o _.-MII
"\,.---
.._-
-"-'.- . --
---
---
.;).39'
3. Middle Creek Historic Cemetery
2002/05/16 MVC 001
8
9
10
r:H
QO
~ 0 -tD
g '7 Z ""
o~""
t;::!'"\)""
~::D::D
-z-
~-c:z
~ ... (i)
-<
"'-
6z
;" f""t
C .
'"
z
\2
:=
f"
;::
z
z
'"
V1
o
>=
V1
V1
"'
"'
'"
-0
I
llg
~ ~ ~
S ~ 0
~ ~ ~ !I ~
!01 < "
~~~;f
!!l n~;
~ ~ - ~ "
; c ~ ~ "
~ ~ > ~
z ~ 52
~~~~~
o
o
c
CO
r
fTl
""
?o ~ fTl
;:: U\
Z ~ 0
~ CO rrJ
0_<
Z Vl fTl
. "r
;::0'< 0
Z 1', -0
U\ :>0 s:::
~<fTl
N f" Z
... .-1
r
r
o
~;o
>~
~ 3'
o -,
Z~
>'<
(j~
::dQ
t:1:j1'"too
rI.)
;::
z
~
u'
S
".
~I
. "'"'"
r... L--;Q
'" I I <
i
."
~ - - -
, - , , < ::
, , , / -
-; ~ .' ) )
-,- , j :.)
, - , -
r , " , , ..;
,/ - , , .. : .,
, :
, ,
. ~
. ': ~>
, - ,
,
\
"
'-
"'0
=<
" "
,.,
~~
" ..,
,.
0"
r;!;
~~
~ 0
1J~
C
o
\
\
8
"z
Cl::!
hj
"'z
~"
g~
c.~
Z
~~
o .Vl
Vl
!
~
I
~
;00 l
;.' ~ :< 1-
:~~;~ J
~,., 3 ~
~4, ~ ~
o
,~
-,
-
n
7' ~
- ~
~.... .:}":
co ,.
~ ~
z Z
== C)
,. ~
~ 0
~
\
""
."~O
~
,,','" / ::~
(
)
-\
< ,
:. - .,
'~= ~
\._J
"",-
'---,-----/
\
/-
./
/
/
SOO'56'13"E
380.00
/...~
,
1-'
I ' I
"'_
I ~
- ".
;::
" '"
'" co
co
i5 <;
'" n
30
1;
, ,
~~',"" ,/
;Q~
I n
... ~
i;i ~
Vl "
~ ~
~ g
~2::
/
I
/
/
I
I
I
I
C~ I
I
\','< ,
1-
I
)
;o~
~, ~
\
;tiC
I :< ne
..... I""Iz
::0 O!:-U
~ :~;
~ ?U 318
~ ~
;; f;
~ 0
~
'" '"
"'0
Vl z
i5 z
"''''
z CD
- ,.
;; e
~5
\
89
151
...---
) }
(" ~....,
I ' ,
1-'
, ' I
:u~
, n
~..-~I -' S
'" '"
--., ,..., r-
~~: ~ i
~-; ~ 3.
"
Pi
~
o
~-
1-,1
~. ; ': I
....,,1 ~,
-~
-;--"
./- .
-~
1-'
~ ,:~: I
~~
I n
- Ie
,. z
'" "'"
~ : s
o. -<
~ :r 8
-= r:.
,. '"
~.::S
/~
G,,'i>G,,~ / \
~" / \
\'t /
~\.>
..,
~
\
\
I
Vl
o
l~
,,-
Ig
:~~
\C~~
~~8
=~
"0
~~
\ I<
~
a5
\ N
if
z
"
\ I
!
\ ~
\
"
,/
~
~
~!!!~ ~
lO~:z: _
,.("l,
~~,.( S2
o ~ Z
I H G)
",'" ~ VJ
:!l~o ~
' :!l CO
'f;
^
!-(l
~u ~
~~~ ~
~jgo ~
'<3'" -<
~i~ 0
5!~:z: ITI
"'~o VJ
~'<~ ~
"'Iil~ '15
" ~ -i
~5!- 0
~i~ ~
~c~
~~:z:
c:"'~
!:: ?<.
~zi
~~~
~~;
8~~
~~'"
~~~
~~.
~
~
,.
'"
!:
~
o
z
~
~
;;
....)...1
< -
"",
I <
- ,.
z
"'''
M '"
Vlc:
~~
z
=~
,. c
~ I
'"
;;
Z
()
I
C
"
()
..=s
/- 'J
, -
"-
I~
01 '"r_.;
./-
Vl I I ~
CD_ "
~o 1JI
'-"'-"
'-"U>
0'-
U>o
:,:' I
I ~,
I I
,
\ - _.
r ,....J
,-'
8~Q~
~r'1~-l
~~0,
. "
("')-",
:""OU"n
r:>' 0
.:....8~~
~..o~
~
'"
00,
"~
~~
"'"
'~ '.
I, / _ :. ,.
"" :,' '--- ' "
/c - , ';-........
II J -........
' I' I,r~
\ .'
/
/
Q
;u ~
, z
.. M
:g .-<
cr.
60
'" I
Z ~
=(7.,
,. 0
~~
:;1']:'
?
~ ~
1j1 Z
60
~~
~-
140
'"
V1
'"
vO."
2:
CXl
""OJ
0...
~""
..-; ,5
.- 0
""
:J.
" .,
r-'1 i/1
,..,
(5 l_
'" 0
Z J:
:r; ,,>
~ 0
~
,/'"
,/'"
.so
,/
/.,
-...L _
/--
,,/ ,/'"
/\'
/'\ \
\ -\
\ -00
,. -<
Z~c\
0-' z
\ ~ ~ ~
ll1 1'; ~
~": '..' \
\~ o.
!~
,.~
~. ~ ~
:> :i: ~
" ~ <;
!' ~ :i
n ". M
~ ~ 0
c '"
'" ~
"'~
\
\
\
!::!::
~ zz
" !f~
!:l ~!::
~ ~~
~ ~~
~ 0,"
o 1;1'"
:z: 0;;1
~ jg!:l
!l5 ~~
~ !:l ':i!
; - :
::u t S;
~ ~ ~
I ~ i
o I ~
~ ~
!:j
or-5r-5555
c: -< 3lsSl-<Sl-<-<-<-<
z !:l g? "'''''''N-
Bl ~ oSl~; Q i " I "
" I ""> ____Qi=
!;J U; ~".::;Pg1::~ll:i!'
~ .'" '<~!:l8-"'<;:"'i:ii
;;0 :j 1P'<.nY'0l0l
rT1 to ...., Vll/)V)(,I)~~
II jg .~~~~~~~~~
io ~ ~jI3;l.,. . . .
'" ",;l
t;; 0
i:; ~
~
g
~5~~~
-i~o~~
~~~SlJl
-oUlQ,;:::{
S~~~~
. r-C"lV'l_
,., . Z
~~h
01"'100
:r~-:r
rr'I,o>
~z~z
~~6~
"'~zE
50 Q
"",:$<:;
z~~~
"
'"
o
"
o
~
o
o
"
". ;r::
" z
'" ".
~~
- 0,.
.~6
I
L ..___
r =: . r'j -..
, ~
I
1---'
I <5
I
"-.."-..
"-..
/::',..:J ,I'
"-.."-..
"-..
"-..
8'
~
/
/
/
,/'"
/ .
,/'"
,.
"''''
I :;
.-. f'.:.. c
::0 -< Z
,..., T 1)
S!},..., s:
~ 0 ,~
........... <::'
~S
8
\
\
\
J'S
C F
VI ~
~
I
\\
\'\ / .r /
-.,~:':\- .rv' V
\.::\ -:,..../ / t /
" ,/V "/
\ V '"-:;( '"
/.:~~;~
Or" ,;" /
~IJ,II ! /
II' irn //,:"/ /
./ 1-",
,/ (~, 1'1
~
""....
.'>
M
,.
i<i
i;i
3
'"
;", ~c
r
'0 r'
~.;:; ~:-:
::; i~:
)..
/"
/"
'b
/"
/"
~~
~~
",'"
,
o
-i
)>
;;0
~
Y.J
"
2!12
V,!::O cotn--o
M!i CC:8el
F '- ~;;j 0 ~
:<> ~ !!iN f'1 !i
OE!l FiS~"
i:.~ f'1 :;! ~
O;E ~ ~
.. !Cl z
~6 ~ . "
."' 8
~ is '" ,
iO~ ~
16
'"
~
'"
/'
~
V1
C
~
~
-0
~
'"
o
~
~
~
Z
'"
'"
~
r-v
5
:n
.
I ~ m, Nom,. c. A"t~ d rod., Oro..' ,
fl\v, - - - ~ =-'''''^
nZ~ --
" 0 G'o
g "7 Ztli:)
~ ;::.. tI\ tI\
!Q~tI\
:,;:Z~
g-cZ
~.. G'
'" -
.~ Z
CD f"\
~ .
Z
~
F
r
!"
r
11:
Z
z
[;l
o
>
'"
'"
U
U
'"
"
:r
(")
.,,0
~~
Z~
~Z
VI"
c",
a~
~Z
o~
VI
!
:0
VI
,,~~
~ 8 U ~
~ ~ ~!!I h1
ri~ ~~ ~
o~~~~
i 15 ; !6 ~
~~,c'
ili~ ~~-~;
,,~ <;l ~ ~ "
~!:l ~~.~~
.,. Z C 0 Z
~ ~ZS!ill
N ~~~~~
o
o
c
CD
r
." ('T1
~ ~ .....
!!; '" ,.,
Z u
" ... 0
d en ~
.z ~ ('T1
11: ~ r
;Z z 0
(Jl ", -0
(Jl ?C s:
~ fT1 rTl
... z
:-l
r
h
~ -
g ~ 2 i? n
,,' r
~ ~ ~
."
)>
:0
;s::
Z
c::
o
z
:-0
CI.)~
~~
~ 5"
Cl.)Q
0'<
Zc::
>~
,....::::-
\,.l .....:
~~
rn~
Q
=:3
;s::
z
z
cr.
1I1
o
>
~
I
I
~
I
I
'\ I
~
I
/) ~
'"
~ I ,,):
[!5 6::
, \ I ~"?"""?"
\ I
, ~ \\
l~ \ \\
~ \ \ ~~ \\ "--- "'~\
Cl &<9 .\,o~
\ ~<ll 0,,;0 r.o.",o~ <0
~"?, .....'&~r.'t,
'?l><? ~ 0 ..
.v!'V .()<
\ ?O/#'~f;''' ....
~~:.,,.P'
9>"'~~ /~
S</,\'" 'l' i-"~~~~ f-~
't,r;,o".-.c,/ .o.",o":.c,;'
,/ y \'~f-'" /
// /
-
"""
~
"\
~
~
,,/
/
1
~ '-... /'" -./
J ~'i
I'~
/ -~
..
>
"
,-,':) -~ (
,'.. '
, "-C>'
~'t-'
'"
""-
~
/ ""- ""'"
~ ~ ,:-""'"
~ /" ""-- ',,..'! 1-',:-""--
///~ /' ,"'~i';':: ~
'~ ','/", "-
/ / ~~ ~~
I'~ '
/
/ /,
, <\''> ~
, , ,
- "
1_:...' '
/
/
\
\
/
/
%9.
/
.~
~
",/
,/"
./
\
\
~>
:i!"
o>Z
,...
pO
:<
\
\
\
\
\
\
{m ~~ t
, ~~! I I
W 9~ ~ ~ ~ <r t
I I
~ ~g~goooo
~Ul ot5 t5 t5 ~~ ~~
~ffiMM~~~~
I'T'l f'Tl1'Tl VI VI VlUl VlVl
1;1 >< >< Q '" '" '" r
:::J iii iii iii 1;1 !! >< ~ Q ('T1
z ~~~:::tg}V;Ul(j)G)
"G)G) B B z~ 2~rr1
~ "'~"'Ul~"'''''''Z
"' ~~~~o~~~o
~ ~",:g>~~~Q
~ C~,",~Vl~rrl()
Ulf,,~3:~Ul!20
Ul5~g ~~
~ ~ n ~
Ul '" ~
Ul ...
o
c:
'"
l!J
o
f
~
l!J~
~
8
is
r
1:#
- OQO
8 ~z~
);~tT\
~::DtT\
...z:!
~-cz
~.. Q
'"
.8 z
CDn
c
'"
z
~
r=
['1
n
o
-oz
~~
z~
"'z
BlG'l
g~
0._
~~
o.~
Vl
!
." ;0
~~Vl
'"
U1
N
':;:
'" -
N
~ '" ~ ~
8 ~~I!;
~ ~"'" ~
r ~~~'"
~ ~~;!il~
~ !!1 ~ ~ co
,. ~ ~
,,~ "~-!lI v;
fl S ~ P ~;>
~!lI ~ '",. ~
Z co Q
~ ~g~~~
N > ::0 -< '-l VI
;::
z
z
'"
Vl
o
>
U1
U1
'"
'"
"
J
I
i II
LLjJ
CJ
o
c:
OJ
r
f"Tl
~
~ ~ f"Tl
_ U1
~ ~ 0
d ~ ~
.z ~ f"Tl
;:: ~ r
z z 0
. "'-0
~~3::
0", f"Tl
"'. Z
... .--l
r
r
(")
g ~I ~~ ~
g : ~11~: --!
g 0 ~ ~ rf,
I ~ "'I ~
~
Q)
~~
~ g'
UJ~
o
Z~
>Q
"",9-
\,.1 :;:,'
==0'0
tzj
UJ::52
Q
:;:,
;::
z
z
,."
U1
S
)>
"~ ~
c..n --
"
?
~~
,~
.~.-~
~~':;:
" -.>'-
~
'"
I n Vl l~ I I I I
i ( ,.
z 'I
I i< ~ ~
J:
'" 1 t
@W " '"
@ I <r I
<> I I
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
'" '" '" '" ~ '" '" '" '" '" '" '" ~ '"
z z z z z Z 2 Z Z Z Z Z
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
r;I r;I ffi r;I r;I r;I r;I r;I r;I r;I r;I r;I r;I r;I
"'~~ ClJ F Vl Vl Vl Vl Vl Vl Vl Vl Vl Vl Vl Vl Vl r 1Il
ilil c ." ." ." '" .., '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" '" f"Tl n
C '" '" '" 1S g X X X X X 1S X X X G) Q
0 0 !6 Vl in in in in in Vl in in in !f
ii,( r (J) ." ." ::l 2 ::l ::l ::l ::l ::l ::l ::l ::l ::l f"Tl
0 ;d 0 0 0 0 Z Z 2 Z Z 2 Z 2 Z ~
Z Vl Vl Vl Z G'l G'l G'l G'l G'l G'l G'l " " Z ~ ~
.~ '" a '" G'l (") .
G) )> 0 0 :il > CD ." Vl Vl :I: Z Z Z Z 0
. . :::l Vl '" Vl ~ 0 > -; a r;I 0 r;I ~ II
!!l '" -; ~ z 0 '"
",'" 0 ,- -; '" '" =< '" '" '" '"
(J) -; 0 ;i ;;; ;:: '" ;:: > !: X ;:: X ~
::l;:l~ z '" c Z >
~ 0 '" z '" (") '" (")
.., ;:: z Z 2 0 " .{ Vl iil 0 0 0 0
. ;:l ^ ~ ~ " '" c 0 '" ;; ~ ;; 2 8
~ Vl ;:: Vl M !: ~ -;
fTI ~ ~ 0 > r;I 0 r;I 0
-< z Vl z ;0 c c
(") '" C :I: (") '" 2 '"
^ !: 0 0
'" M 2
!-Q :r 5l a~~~~ z @ d
~ 5l iil Vl
g g ~ c
,. ~ - -:I '" '" ~
z z g~ g~
51 0 ~ 0 co'" '"
C ~ ~ '"
ill ill
'"
Fil~ Nom.: G: \Aulocoo'\projdwg$ \Orowings \Cm(J()d\plans \ GRAO[\D,IOND GRAOC,dwg
/ ~ ------ ,/ -./ /
;J < /' J '--- '-i ,--:)
:;: >/~/Sl ~-- . \ ,;';:>" /
;-~_/ / -=- C _ /~~r " ~ t-- (J) >- _ -\
,-:I.-- ../ I r r- J/ I (" '-- ........ '--- --........./
I 'I-I ~ - --- r r/ 1 ( --- --- ................ ~~--- \
I ~-"~ ~ \ ........",7........ \
'_/~~1-- ~ ( " "f ___ J \
I '\ \ \ \ \" \ / --- I "'( --- - ~
i - - I" \, :f. <$ I' SOO'S6'13"E
I \ \" '-- 'f ~ t 380.00
\. r-'-' I ~~"
','I I<V\'~~~
'\ l "" "",-- -t9
" I'" '-- ~ '"
(-~ ~I "\ " " " '-- ........ ~ =t
'I 1-" ........~_{~5
-T~ ~___ -~ 'i'
.,.)_1 - - - z
i3
[;
............. ~
z'If<'O
/--1
/
./
~
/,
"
~ ,
........~
\.....
~'\. \
"
(.::.\ ~
~
~
/ /:) I '" ~ ~
~f:~ !:>;, ~
~..,'/....... ~ 'I'> ~
/ ! ' '1 ',8 i,I,
~J <((.'Ii ;,i ,~ ;"~
\ X \~\,~~" /;;/ _
; "" ,,\'\\{ II' ~
\ It) ~ ~:f o~ rn
"' 1" /'<]; ll1~_AJ
",G'l
) II I ~~
..J ) / 0'-
_ J / / ~~
- = 1 1 iJ 0"
-I
~
/
/
r-'-,
I I I
I
)
r-'-'
I ' I
-...-
",.^,
--/
~-.-,
I I I
( ,"'
\,~ )
I
--1
;0
~
Vl
15
z
Vl
]>
~ili
0;::
o
1jj~
2lQ
iilgj
02
..,,,
0(")
..,c
:~
i;j~
I
---<
I
r-'-'
I ' I
~ \ d~8
~\ ~~~
.~ \ ~~~
"''''
~~
\ r,"'
,~ )
\
d~~
,,0...
;o~i"
>0'-
~..,.,~
~Cj~
"..,
;0'"
O~
"''''
\
\
\
\
\
\
"
;0
~
,.,
o
..,
o
;0
/
~
/
\
-,
~
~
/
,,/'"
,,/'"
-u
o
z
o
s rn
a fTl
~ ~
I
o
f"Tl
--l
~
,.
\
\
'"
/ "-
/ h "-
~~\ ',' ""
h~~' . /"- "-...
C~\',' / /', "- ~
'" / I" 1 "" '-...
~/ ,'11"" '-...
_ (I {: '>-- '-... '-...
I '-... !, ' -' '-...
1 '-... '^i: ' '-...
/ (,:e; ,f";/5 ;:-", iY~i: I '-... '-...
, i- ~'\~ 1 '-... r '-...
( ~"" -~~ / '- '-
'I II" /1 '- '-----
) \ ,,,\" Iii '-...
" " " / J
\ '-... ",1'1/ / II '-...
/, ,." ." '-
, 'h':~l;;i '^
,/,/ '-...
'"
'.
r:;p
<5 0 GlO
8 ~ ZtD
~ ""0 f1'\ f1'\
-<::Df1'\
:;:Z::D
~-c:Z
~.. Gl
,.,
.~ Z
~ n
:0
z
(Il
,;;
:=
!"
r,J~ Nom~: c: \AllfClc-od\pr
ojdwvs\Orowi"9s\[
mOfld\plan$ ItA YOUTlfJ.lON.
'0 LAYO/)rdw9
\
\
)
__L
/
,./
~ -
/
I
/
/
/
/
"-
I
I
,...-
-/
..........
..........
.......... /'
..........J
(
-~/
/
- ,~)
,-,'",) -
-).', '
, \./
Y
;::
Z
z
,.,
(Il
o
-<
)>
(Il
(Il
C<
C<
"
1J
J:
n
,,0
>ti
zC
z""
!;)~
Vl"
0'"
" Z
0."
>~
Z'"
0;0
jll
V1
C
;0
~
~
Vl
\
I \ "
\ "
\ I " "-
1""1 '&
\" I r
\
\ " .-'
-
(
/
/
~;;~ 0
--.
( ("
1" )
I
--~
( ("
",)
..,
)> N
:00
~~r'1
~ ...
b Q;I ~
.Z ~ <
~ ~ p
.",0
~ )> -U
o < ~
N~rr1
... Z
.-1
..,
o
OJ
\
\
\
\
\
,/
(Il
I g
I~
~
,/
,/
,/
,/
~
g
,
,/.
,/
/'
I~
l~
I~
()
"
~
~
.2
I
l(ll
<D-
~o
",'"
.V'
O~
":0
~.I
I
I~
UJ~
~(j)
~~
UJ(;)
o
2:8
>~
(j-
~::::j
~~
UJtr)
n;oOf'T'l
00"""):-
C,., (Il
Z (Il~
:2~8,
~Ol\Jb
s::::>.r..J"n
.:....3~~
\ II ;;:~
\ .:;:
ct~
>--'l
o
~
t"'"
>
n
::0
M
Cf)
II
~
C)1
1\)
;;;
~
,.,
(Il
o
;::
l~ l~-;~
\
,/
"
"'-
'", ,/ ,/
~
.~
,/
,/
.,/
.,/.,/
.,/.,/
,/--
,~./,/ -
/'/<
./
.,/
/>.,/
/.,/
.,/
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
{
~~ <b
I (
I ~;:: I
OJ: I
io
N I 'f.' r
I c.p
~ @ ~ <r
(Il
g 0 0
'" g g g
Z Z g 0
0 0 Z Z Z Z g
M -< 0 0 Z
'" M M S 0 S z
(Il (Il '" M 0
(Il (Il M
'" '" (Il (Il '"
!S '" '" (Il (Il
X X '" '" r
(Il Vi X m
-< :oJ Vi Vi !S X X '" r'1
z -< :oJ (Il Vi Vi X
C> z Z :oJ ~ Vi G)
C> C> Z Z Z :oJ ~
0) " C> C> C> Z Z r'1
2! 0 '" Ul (Il C) C) Z
X J:
~ Vi )> -< Z Z 0
;:: Z 0 .0:
Z :0 :oJ ::; :0 0 ~ 0
Z )> ;:: :0 m '"
0 :0
C " C) :0 )> ;:: X
(Il ~ 0) .0: Ul ~ '" ()
C ;:: ~ (Il 0 0
Ul ;= ~ ~ Z
" :0 c:
Z J: C
f;l ~ () :0
0
Ul ~
0
C
:0
~
g
Z
o
M
(Il
'"
!S
(Il
:oJ
z
C)
;;I
,.,
'"
;-
Z
,.,
(Il
r:;p
~ ~ ~g
'" .:::.. '" '"
e;""O",
-<=:li)
~z-
,,<z
~.. (j)
'"
'"
~z
~n
'"
2
'"
"
r
r
['1
J::
z
2
'"
'"
o
-<
> ~
'" '"
~ ~
!:j ~
~=; ~.;
'" V> ~ ~
g e ~ > "'
o !;Jili~
'i' SO
~ ~ h~
~ n~~~
I Ia O!6 'i'
~ ~~X ~
p, )>. > c::
z ~~~~;
~ ,"!2 - !ii V>
~ J: n >-
;~ :!::~
~ ~Ha~
o
o
c
CO
r
..,rr1
.., 0
~ t;; rr1
ZeD'" 0
~ Vi rr1
On <
.J:: > rr1
-<,
J:: ~ 0
z > -0
'" ~ :s:::
~ 2 ~
.p.,."..~
r
r
()
~ J~~ ~i
o n' i::'
~. . o-n
~ > x
~ ~ R
'- ~
~ "
~
,.
'"
;;::
z
S
o
Z
rn
~
UJ
o
z
>::2
Cjg
~
t=j
UJ
~
Cb
.....
~
:::.:
J::
Z
;E,
V1
S
)>
I '~. c.n ~ ~
01 , ~
I ;:
.. ~ . ....
nle NQmfl. c: \Avlor;o"l,p,ojfi"'l}s\Orow'''9s\(m,,,,';/\pIOflS \OCTAI(S \0( TAI(.rt...q
n
,,0
>z
z~
ffl~
"'z
VlCl
0'"
:> Z
o.~
~~
00
2.
/
.>
~
~
~
g
~
.
~
"
~
z
~
e
=;-c;
~ g'
;'rn
~=:
~ ,
=-",
='<7
-~
_0
,V>
"-'co
'=,
~i
~
rtb
t-~~JU'
e It
I
'"
< A.~
o 0
~ e ro-g
II" ...
L ::
W~
~
19
" "
~5
cr;;
~o
~ :t:
C)
c V>
0-0
~
(,;
n -j
C :<>
~6
:e- 50
ao
C'lo
C r"1
~ ~
'" F
l!)
"'''
s.~
~0
,,0;;:
~3:
v>0
~~
0""
c'
~~
"'",
'co
"
" ~
, ~
<
;;'-
'll ~
no
~
='
"
;;;
"
~
<7
"
o
t~
'"
V>
-V1
I-j
::0)>
OZ
co
c;>
I::O
o
vV1
;:2 r-,
<n
r"1 .
=>:=
,,0
~z
:::.
,<
I
I
"
;~ -<
~n
gl ~ ~ 3
~ 5 LI'.
~~ :
1?U"
~.5 . ~~
" -
? ~
..... ,<
'"
$
'"
2
'"
....' -I~ Or-- ;t"1'
. c ::r 0
~~:;g,~; ~;::
oo.OO~\ -..
~ ~ ~ i. ~ ~
~g3~~[
['~(iQ;~ s~
~ ? 3' 3 ~ .(1) ~ II
.. ~ a ~ K ~ ~- Q
m ~ 9. ~ 3' ~ ~
\II ill < '
0''' '" - ~
'0-0 :r:: 0
.,. m IV 0
j
~~~:
,'\" l'l' _ CI
~~~;
Q 0 '
1: ,,<D
; ~ ~
"",
"
'"
'"
"
".
'"
'"
o
~
H~
;r g F.
,."
_0
~~
. ;;
{.~
-.
~i
l~
o
,
"
~
fT1
r
(")
o
z
(/)
...,
;:0
C
(")
...,
(5
Z
fT1
Z
...,
~
~ :
g
,
'"
~ ~
!"
o,,~
~S;'"
fr;lo
!::l~
~~
-"
6?O
;o!5
z
"''''
iid
S;2
"",
~~
00
c>
~~
-<0
'"
-<
>
F
~
"',,'"
gS;~
~r;lo
!;;~~
~~~
(')~.."
26~
(I};;:O!;
. z
"''''
~~
~~
:;!>
z
>0
e~
o
'"
-<
>
F
:"
~~~
>-<
-"'n
r",~
-<
!~
CD..,
b~
;o~
CD'"
~~
~~
:;!i<
80
;o~
",0
;00
>'"
~~
i-'
0"'"
~S;~
>-<
-"'n
r",~
-<
"'0
!...,
""
a?o
;o!5
2
\!!'"
Od
~2
)>'"
!;;~
86
;0>
",,,,
o
~g
,,~
F
;-'
i-'
zCti~
:;!~.-
",-<~
~8~
>>",
~8~
2
~~CJ
Z"~
~~Z
>"''''
. _ '"
ZlJ)
I
F
'"
'"
'"
WI:-:;!;:"'>>
'ta ~",-<~grr
z::Q J:zo
o~~~~~~:J:
:;!-<zr;l"'elz~
r'Tl~o<bOG))>
G)>i'~lr'T1d~
>F"';i\5~ '"
;;1wn ;:FO",
<r'T1c:~z~::t~
~Z~f:~~~f=
r;~~~~~..,,~
~a~~::E~z
o:r~o~z~
~r'Tl~~b~~
r -or-
M z8
o
'"
0"'"
;:gs:~
~r;lo
~~~
;;.!.~
"'''''1
~~~
~o~
-<lJ)'"
Fr~
:;:'"
-<
,,>
oz
"'0
n>
S!el
no
;0'"
"'-<
M~
[/)>~[/)
~ 5>~
'" ",;;10
;;I c "'~
~ ~;;Io
CO;O 1 "'l1
o
.."O....."Tl
~~b~
:e F::Oz
'" "'"
i ~~ ()
~ >'~ 0
z J=2~ z
(') r'Tlo Vl
~ ::j~ ~
CD ~o c
8~ ~
Sl~ (5
z
Z
:-' 0
iT!
U1
CD
~~
"'-<
lJ)'"
~~
!i:';i\
;0",
~~
S;~
;;1r
W
"'"
>-
-<2
I",
0-<
"'~
r
'"
o
~n
",S!
2;;j
Qi!;
~~
~~
>~
lJ)'-
~z
,,'"
g~
;;I:
"''''
2'"
n>
:c ;0
Z
n
c
'"
'"
~
@
::1
'"
'"
p
~Q~~~g~
~~~:;!6~~
:EVlol"Tl>>G")
UdotD:::lt5g>
~fT1/'Tl~I/106
r->);! )>~
",Cx8"'z~
9lt"';o","'>
~I"TlZtDa-l~
Yl~dOl~OO
oc;;2og~
!5[qi!;Z W
~"'8:rs:i2!
Nr>"1. i"'l"Tl!:
fTlO/TlV1>z
VJ:gr;;~~g
~S~~~VJ
~;;H~~d~
C)e~~Z~
::O-ir- tx:l
CD ~ ('Tl
'"
;;j
I
'"
:-J
n
c
;0
'"
~
~~~
~z~
3:tDM
~~~
~Q~
~n~~
~~~
2[/)>
Q~~
~::tJO
no"
'">>
S!O~
Yt;l=
~p
~b
2
-<n
"'c
'"
W
CD
>'"
-<'"
:;!~
"'-<
>
nz
>0
Q~
Wo
>'"
~~
lJ)r
'"
;;j
I
o
...
"
o
'"
'"
'" '"
W '"
> 2
'" I
Z g
~c"
,,,;:is;
n::i~
~G1lJ)
-<
O::?'"
"'ul?i
~5~
1::"''''
z~"
'" >
~~~
U)~g
ej-<"
, '" 0
~o~
~~Vl
;;1 "
~
:;!
o
~
'"
~
"
,
~
!:i
."
fT1
Z
(")
fT1
I
=E
o
o
o
-0
o
~
(")
o
z
(/)
...,
~ 9 ~
() 0 g:
...,
~ E
"
Ro.
~8
~~
~f;
-<-<
<0
;0'"
"'-<
~o
.~~
8~
jIl~
~>
r
<'-
g~
-<2
~~
"':0
"'-<
-<r
Oz
~~
n
~
'"
co,
::;
~
(5
,
'"
;::
o
c
3
)>
f!?
r"1
1~11
:::0" J:
. 0
'.
'"
n-
,,~
n
o
z
;0 !~
~n
"'--<
mO
>>z
"
,,>
rl
"'>>
~
"'OI...CO..,Z
~oU.o~~
:.'a,:;2n'~
~. ~ iJ ~
~'~ ~'~. ~
t: C:;)l::
3 ' ,
o ,j ~
!' [~.~
.. ~_3 :
g ~ .. :::
i~ g;
~ .
. g
~~
<0
~~
o
Sl
V'
~
.
o
[/))>("")>
~8~~
O;;of'Tl[/)
)>onr>"1
el~6~
o 2
r>"1-lU)>
....jOUlZ
~('):rO
~~~~
~0~r;1
;;1""''''
(JI~z~
Ul;DV);o
~~~~
lG1rr>"1
~b8
Z
!"
~:r"
"'0>
Q~~
~c",
~E~
,"c
"",n
>"'2
~g~
t5i6~
~~~
V)~~
~~~
~~~
iTi;Cj
"'0;0
2~
I
9
!-" ~
>[/) o~
:~ ~m
~> ~~
a2~ ~~
2z ~~
I;i\ "Z
0::0 )>0
,,-< Z
t f'Tl :z:Vi
~M~;B
:"< ~ p1 0
'" J::
~ :r
'" '"
>
'"
'"
..
~
@
~g
~ ~
~~
00
Q.~
-~
,..
I 1.3 \ /2~'
I -~-t.
'-n ---r.: 'I
e~i [I
l:t :.I~ II
W ~ i
~. II
II
II
II
II
!I
Ii
-)}
;:;
;::;::;::
:J :'0 ~
000
000
-l,.......l -l
co co co
01iJ"l0"l
".)--
"'00".)
~;~
0"'
, , '"
::3~ ~
:i ~
"
00
~o
g~
~..
g ~
g'~
2:~
. c
~g;
~~: &"
'~
is -
.E ~.
V>
".
e. x,
.s
. ,.
o ~
=.
V>
i ,.:, ~ '::':,.:~
!_ l~
[
." ,;:. ~g ~.,
,':-, "'~ ""~.
\ i\i-
--. ;~ ~
, ~ g. ,
~
.
<;
11
~
()
o
z
U1
~
C
()
-l
<5
z
z
o
iT!
o
~
"'-'VlO-l
::!)'-+':T
s.g.oro
~ ~~ b'
_~cn~
g-~Qd
" ;:>: 3 ~
_:T 0
oS':E .,
:':'-~3
~ roc
o.~In
o ...
"< 8 V)
.-.~o
~,,~ g;
ON'
.g ~ CD
~ (I) ~
s: '* CD
o ... x
" ""
~3~
_ ~ 0.
:T
5- ~ Q,
" -
~ ~'~
~8 ~
.f:o. 5 :E
g-[~
~ ~ 3'
~...'"
908
_0
.....:eCO
o 0 ~
~~2.
; ~ 0
0"... ~
,,:To
" "...
V> "
~In ~
~ [2-
~ "
~3~
c
0. V> II>
o ......
~ g- ~
~.
.~~ ~ ~
~ ~.; ~
:I ~
o ~
~ ~ ..'
.....-=-01,
C ,
,,-<
"2O~
.;.',; 1:
;J
J;
tT)>
" =
~~
0_
'"
" V>
P-o
"
"
II>
In
o
0.
0.
3.
~ ~
o
0.
3.
'"
Ii
V
:::
p
o
o
~
;:;
n
g
3
c
~
3
c
~
tT
"
~
"
I
<
"
'"
"
~
"
II>
"
"
0.
"
0.
o
"
0.
:;:
"
II>
~
~.
5'
3.
...
CD
~
o
g;
N.
"
0.
~
:T
:T
o
>;
II>
i5'
ill
tT
o
~ (3
~ ~
:T
s,
g
o
"
0.
3.
9.
:;
"
V>
o
0.
3
c
~
9
o
V1
()
:e
,...,
--l
-<
-0
() "',
)>
r
;::
z
tf) I! 'I if
~ I I
Gl I I , --,-
~ ~~~:' ~.: i I
g ~P~0 I~i
~ ~~~ I: ~
n nVl . - 0
~ ~tp~:S ~
:PoD (J1J""'l
=:j rrl2)Orv
~ g0~g
R> ~g~~
E;~~~c
ClZ()C;::
, 8~lflZ
g: -<~~~
n L..Ii'"I(./lLf'J
If) ~CO""~
-I r- COr (")m
o r---~~~
~ ~ (jl::O(')
~ 6 o~g
r:: 0 Z ::0
~ ~ ~ ~
;0 A ~
I '" :0
o :0
~ -<
(j)
--l
:::0
[T1
[T1
--l
(j)
[T1
()
--l
o
Z
r
~
31
"
:5
r
fT1
G)
fT1
Z
o
z
g
"
g
l<1
,;j
R
c
z
'"
I
I,.
'3
\~
r
~
IJj
fT1
Z
(")
~
Z
"
\
~ \
II \ [I
~ I \ :1
;!
1-
~ \
~
n ~
g g
~9:
o :>
~\Q
o.g
o "
c 0
:::V>
Ro
o <il
"
0.0
~tT
o "
2:",
" ~
o
o 0.
< "
S,c.
O="l
~ ~
g g
...0.
:T
:}l C'
" g
Vl =:
" 0
c.:>
3. 0
" In
~...
"
tT3
~, "8
=> ~
II> 0
_...(
3 II>
3 "
" 0.
9, 3.
o "
i~
""a
o
V>
5.
!"
7?~~~g~
~~[S::Q~
~~g~~g-[
:J OOJ:r:JOl
3-<::r~~a.
o 0 ctl 0
g;2"~.c-i~
(D' :.. Vl :r .VI
o.t1l0~3:
~~a.~bro
..... g.::"I \1l O~
~~.~ a -Ig
.g3;r;~Q
"0 t1l .... 0 "'-J"<
~F-~-~g
o :IN.-a.
~(lh.o
g~~3 s:~
.... 3 0 VI Cb e.
~~~-g-g~
.-o....~o
~~~OOnn=
~tT
~ g : ~ o' co
0. =r :J Vl
-gVlgg'O~
C Vl (D...- a..
:J::r a. t1l fl)
a. !?- 3 S' 0 a.
(j) - 0 'f> _~,
~g-~3 "5'
~ 0 0
o ~ S' ~ "0
Q2..~2:g~
~tl2.~ 5.8
[ ~.~' g ~ ~
....;oa.~~
03:5.~oO'l
-0.:1 .-()
g8~~:.ro~
~-I0::l-lC
Ul ~~..o ~;:o
~ 2..~ ~ (t):J
~35g--9
() x' ~ g ~ ~
ro ('J () 0
2. ~:r S'
:>
In
~
o
!6 5
8 c
~ l<1
~ ~
<
CD
I~
100
,-
+
c;&
s~
"'''
"0
F, I
2) I
2-- __._L_l.
9
~
"
g
z
o
~
<
~ O"tl n"'"
R~~~~
zg~g~
C ;ol"'l ;0
~ 0
I!i
'"
.. .';~.',I:'.~~
"
>1:;
~
011>
n...
"'<il
n "
gG;"
~9-;
2~
n c
g:~
:> 0.
~g-
~ ~
o 5"
g'"
" ~
...0
0;;'
_ 3'
:T'"
"
:T
V> 0
;:;.:c
" ;;;
33
c c
~~
~g
~n
~.~
c.=>
" "
0.0.
00
:>-
0._
3~
o
S' ~
00.
:j' 0
" -
0.
'"
<70
-<g.
5'_
'" 0
n ;;.
?~.
00.
" 0
Q~
'"
2.3-g.ro:f
() e. ~..g ro
5" ~~ g ~
5 ro n ~ro
~;'"g rD"3
N' (() (n C
(0 ~~OVl
~~[2;
o CT c' (t) ro
~ ro? 3 ^
Vl~r"8~
~ CD ~ g~.
tT -<"
5' ~"g a. 0
Q~2.'~~
-0 a. VI ::r Cb
a~' :5"~ f
~ g 0 ~, a
~ ~ 8.~'~'
..0 a.. :f 1.0 0-
c 0
~ o~ Q 8
:~3~9-.
CD .- c :r '::'
g~~~g
~9..g~ ~
n_~go
g~~ln=
..... _.....-
2. ~ ~ 2 3'
VI 0 a. C (l)
Ro ro :f ~'Yl
rog~a.-i
~ooo~
..0 :::-0 S' ()
'< I 0 Ul 0
a. ~. VI, C :J
(ii' ro 2-. rn :;-
'" < 0
-g' g : -; ~
::-:0.0"0-'
gg.~~~
f5"~ ~3g
~ ro 20 3. ~
" 0 :>
y> tf) ~~
~)
i
-I
i...,
i~1
1m :
I~i
. I'"
,0
, .
I
,
I
I':;:
:....;
r=
r
C
V1
-l
;:0
)>
...,
(5
Z
^
fT1
-<
:>'"
C "
3"
<7~
ill...
!" 0
5'
"
o
'(j
C
-0
o
z
o
IJj
fT1
Z
(")
I
o
~
r
tJI ..p. ~
3.
e.
"
~
~
n
~
"
=>
::r
Q
N.
o
=>
Q:
!!l.
C;
0.
3
"
:>
II>
o.
"
.11>
o
~
0. ~
~ g
g 0-
0.
o
<7 :>
o '<
R- ~
"
o
<
9.
o
:>
OJ~
~~
~i<i
g~
g5
~~
:5
l:~
8
I
o
c
V1
fT1
OJ
~%
,,~
7"'
0>
s~
c~
~~
g~
~
D:Q'"
.<.... '
1~?
r)"'"
. ~,':'
.,,"
,~n ~
;'9,
=<
-0
fT1
V1
;;
",
r
I;:
I::
~
~~
7'
g:?
!~
it
."
CO~
~Z'"
1)~>
2v>~
l~~
~
'?
o
g
~
z
~~
~:<
~ "
'"
CIl -
0'"
::1 0
o
<
V.
"
~
--<
::r
"
~
~
"Ul
ro 9
< -
~~
"'0
~~
::..:~.
_iil
011>
V>
V> In
. :T
~
<7
"
V>
o
~
N
"
0.
o
=>
0.
"
;;
C;
"
C;
0.
(")
o
z
V1
...,
;:0
C
(')
:::!
o
z
z
o
-l
fT1
V1
tf)
"
C;
o
=>
"
()
~
9.
o
n
e.
OO'fTIUl:Tn-Vl
""\ro:J:roo:r~
I.OO(Jl:Jro.....
() ..., -. = Vl
g ~ ~ _. ~ ~ ~ (b
~ s:. ~ ~ ~ ~~, ~
2 ~. c ::;,~ ro
;la.)>g-~g~~
.-g-~.....o'o9..
::r ~.;:.:::r 2: ::l-
~ uS g"~. ~ ~ a. ~
n 9.. ~ ~ 8 ~"O
30 ...... <0-
C'D:Jro9.. s..=Q
o ~ 0 0 o' 0' ~
~ 2 ~'6' "'0 ,::l ro a.
(Ono::>o -'0
~6,::J. 3~~Ul
:J8ro~:6-~
Q":J3.......li)nO
'<~o :l(l)~
s:Q.Q.Q~o:J
(1)~OUlUl5.g
9 9- 5. ~ g; 5' s:
'< 0 0 ~ o-~ (ii'
~Ul~~(l)~
r;;::.:lil 3 r;"2.
~3(DVlQQ.Q
3"0 9-.5" 5' 0- :J
3' ~ ~ = ~'< g
l,Q....oO":J-Q.
..... '< (J) lil lil ;r
o 0 0.(00
:J "0 - 0 --
. gs::J5g~
g 9: ~ 0 ~'< =r
o..::l<'O"O o~
.-.lfJ 2. ~ 5' -.. _
::ra. 0-""10
<'0 _, 0 ~ _ 0 0
".......:Jro....o
0" _" 3 '"
g .VI ~ Q f S' g
~:r -. _~ VI
g~~,gQgQ
Q ~ ~ :LO -0 :.
ftl ....... '-" ... ... _
~.V1 g' ~. g Q' ~
Q (1) V1::l .-
:=n9..g~o~
~3~Q~~$
o 0 ~
='<
(')
o
~
o
n
g
"
o
=>
~
c
~
o
=>
II>
::r
~
n
o
:>
~
3
Vi.
o
n
o
"
o
"
.g 0
='
'l1
o
:>
0.
V>
"
C;
:;:
c
iil
V>
II>
"
0.
3
"
:>
'"
'!:
I
...
V'
..
I
o
o
o
'"
;:;
"
"
3.
'"
3
"
o
II>
~
D:
o
11
MINNESOTA HISTORICAL SOCIETY
March 28, 2006
Dear Heritage Preservation Commission Member or Staff:
We wanted to bring to your attention proposed legislation that would impact your work as a
Heritage Preservation Commission (HPC) member or staff person.
Last week, the Minnesota House added a provision to HF 2846, the eminent domain reform
bill, which would define state and local historic preservation designation as a "taking" and
require payment for daIIiages resulting from the designation. A copy of the proposed House
language is enclosed.
This language is currently in the House version of the bill, but is not contained in the Senate
version of the bill, passed by the Senate on March 27th. Our initial read of the language is
that it would be detrimental to the work ofHPCs, but we wanted to get some additional
feedback from HPC members and staff.
We would ask you to do two things:
. First, please review the proposed language and give us your feedback on how the
proposed language would impact your work as a Heritage Preservation Commission
member or staff member. You can email or call David Kelliher or Britta Bloomberg
at the Minnesota Historical Society. David can be reached at 651-297-8085 or
david.kelliher@mnhs.org; Britta can be reached at 651-296-5471 or
britta.bloomberg@mnhs.org.
. Second, if you have concerns about the language. please communicate this to your
House and Senate members as soon as possible. A copy of legislative contact
information is att~9hed: . (If you need help determining who your legislators. are,
please let us know. Additional information on contacting legislators is available on
the MHS website at: www.mnhs.org/historvmatters)
Since these bills are moving quickly through the legislative process, your quick action is
requested and much appreciated. Please do pass this information on to others who may be
interested. Let us know if you have any additional questions.
~:: ~~
Britta Bloomberg - 0
Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer
~
David Kelliher
Legislative Liaison
345 Kellogg Boulevard West/Saint Paul, Minnesota 55102-1906/Telephone 651-296-6126
79TH DAY]
MONDAY, MARCH 27, 2006
5701
Holberg from the Committee on Transportation Finance to which was referred:
LH. F. No. 28;;lA bill for an act relating to eminent domain; defining public use or purpose; prohibit~g the use
of eminent domam for economic development; requiring clear and convincing evidence for certain takings;
providing for attorney fees and other additional elements of compensation; making other changes in the exercise of
eminent domain; amending Minnesota Statutes 2004, sections 117.025; 117.075, subdivision 1; proposing coding
for new law in Minnesota Statutes, chapter 117.
Reported the same back with the following amendments:
Page 5, after line 20, insert:
"Sec. 7. r117.184510THER REGULATORY TAKINGS.
*
A state or local !!overnment preservation desiwution adopted on or after Au!!ust 1. 2002, that reduced the fair
market value or real property or interferes with the owner's use and quiet eniovrnent of the property. constitutes a
regulatorv tabn!! for which the owner must be paid iust compensation. The state or local !!overnment mav repeal or
amend the official control or historic preservation desiwatlon to eliminate the adverse impact on the propertv
instead of paying damages."
Page 6, after line 9, insert:
"SuM. 4. Use of appraisal at commissioners' hearing. An appraisal of the !!oin!! concern must not be used or
considered in a condenmation commissioner's hearin!!. nor may the appraiser who prepared the appraisal testify.
unless a copv of the appraiser's written report is provided to the opposing party at least five davs before the hearin!!."
Page 6, line 13, delete "of the points of access to and"
Page 6, line 14, delete "exit from" and insert "of the driveway access into and out of'
Page 6, line 16, delete "and one year" and insert a period
Page 6, delete fine 17 ,
Page 6, before line 18, insert:
"A claim for compensation under this section must be made no later than one year after the cOIt1pletion of the.
proiect that eliminated t..'1e driveway access. Compensation must not exceed (1) the addition of revenue from the
two previous years. minus (2) the addition of cost of goods sold from the two previous years."
Page 6, line 20, delete "similar house or building of equivalent size" and insert "comparable property"
Page 6, line 22, before the period, insert ". to the extent the dama!!es will not be duplicated in the compensation
otherwise awarded to the owner of the property"
Amend the title accordingly
Correct the title numbers accordingly
With the recommendation that when so amended the bill pass and be re-referred to the Committee on Ways and
Means.
The report was adopted.
District/Member /Pa rty
Room'
Phone
(651) 296.
2006 Minnesota House of Representatives Members
Phone
(651) 296.
District/Mem ber /Pa rty
Room'
48B
43B
19A
3A
39B
35A
51B
12B
29B
25A
35B
45B
56A
61A
24B
25B
37A
31B
62A
52B
49A
29A
28A
6A
47A
27A
23B
17A
2A
58B
19B
64A
41A
16A
21B
26B
36B
12A
50A
54A
24A
48A
22B
39A
66B
15B
13A
46B
8A
36A
34B
60B
47B
14B
4B
7A
7B
43A
23A
67B
13B
59B
60A
56B
15A
20B
34A
Abeler, Jim (R) ........................................................ 509 ...................................1729
Abrams, Ron (R)..................................................... 585...................................9934
Anderson, Bruce (R) ............................................. 437...................................5063
Anderson, Irv (DFL) .............................................. 321 ...................................4936
Atkins, Joe (DFL) ................................................... 217 ...................................4192
Beard, Michael (R)................................................. 577 ...................................8872
Bernardy, Connie (DFL) ...................................... 233...................................5510
Blaine, Greg (R)...................................................... 545 ...................................4247
Bradley, Fran (R) .................................................... 563...................................9249
Brad, Laura (R) ....................................................... 581...................................4229
Buesgens, Mark (R}............................................... 445...................................5185
Carlson, Lyndon (DFL)......................................... 283...................................4255
Charron, Mike (R) .................................................. 571 ...................................4244
Clark, Karen (DFL) ................................................. 303 ...................................0294
Cornish, Tony (R) ................................................... 487...................................4240
Cox, Ray (R) .............................................................413 ...................................7065
Cybart, Lioyd (f-li.................................................... 539 ...................................5506
Davids, Gregory M. (R) ........................................ 477 ...................................9278
Davnie, Jim (DFL).................................................. 309 ...................................0173
Dean, Matt (R) ........................................................ 417 ...................................3018
DeLaForest. Chris (R) ........................................... 503...................................4231
Demmer, Randy (R) .............................................. 597 ...................................9236
Dempsey, Jerry (R) ............................................... 575 ...................................8635
Dill, David (DFL)..................................................... 31 5 ...................................2190
Dittrich, Denise (DFL).......................................... 371 ...................................5513
Dorman, Dan (R) ................................................... 517 ...................................8216
Dorn, John (DFL)................................................... 201...................................3248
Eastlund, Rob (R)................................................... 449...................................5364
Eken, Kent (DFL).................................................... 329 ...................................9918
Ellison, Keith (DFL) ...........................;................... 229 ...................................8659
Emmer, Tom (R) ..................................................... 523 ...................................4336
Entenza, Matt (DFL) ............................................. 267 ...................................8799
Erhardt, Ron (R) ..................................................... 591 ...................................4363
Erickson, Sandra (R) ............................................. 473..................................6746
Finstad, Brad (R) .................................................... 379 ...................................9303
Fritz, Patti (DFL) ..................................................... 239 ...................................8237
Garofalo, Pat (R)..................................................... 429 ...................................1069
Gazelka, Paul (R).................................................... 529 ...................................4333
Goodwin, Barbara (DFL)..................................... 331 ...................................4331
Greiling, Mindy (DFL) .......................................... 259 ...................................5387
Gunther, Bob (R).................................................... 559 ...................................3240
Hackbarth, Tom (R) .............................................. 409 ...................................2439
Hamilton, Rod (R) ................................................. 423 ...................................5373
Hansen, Rick (DFL) ............................................... 221 ...................................6828
Hausman, Alice (DFL) .......................................... 245...................................3824
Haws, Larry (DFL) .................................................. 277 ...................................6612
Heidgerken, Bud (R)............................................. 507 ...................................4317
Hilstrom, Debra (DFL) ......................................... 375 ...................................3709
Hilty, Bill (DFL)........................................................ 207 .......,...........................4308
Holberg, Mary Liz (R) ........................................... 443...................................6926
Hoppe, Joe (R)........................................................ 537...................................5066
Hornstein, Frank (DFL) ........................................ 227 ...................................9281
Hortman, Melissa (DFL)...................................... 377 ...................................4280
Hosch, Larry (DFL) ................................................ 211 ...................................4373
Howes, Larry (R) .................................................... 451 ...................................2451
Huntley, Thomas (DFL) ....................................... 335...................................2228
Jaros, Mike (DFL)................................................... 291...................................4246
Johnson, Jeff (R) .................................................... 401 ...................................5511
Johnson, Ruth (DFL) ............................................ 389 ...................................8634
Johnson, Sheldon (DFL) ..................................... 243 ...................................4201
Juhnke, AI (DFL) .................................................... 281...................................6206
Kahn, Phyllis (DFL)................................................ 255 .................;.................4257
Kelliher, Margaret Anderson (DFL)................. 261 ...................................0171
Klinzing, Karen (R) ................................................ 567 ...................................1147
Knoblach, Jim (R) .................................................. 453...................................6316
Koenen, Lyle (DFL) ............................................... 337...................................4346
Kohls, Paul (R)......................................................... 421 ...................................4282
53A
9A
63B
44B
40B
66A
30A
1B
55A
59A
22A
67A
65B
9B
57B
53B
Krinkie, Philip (R)................................................... 365 ...................................2907
Lanning, Morrie (R) .............................................. 593 ...................................5515
Larson, Dan (DFL) ................................................ 287 ...................................7158
Latz, Ron (DFL)........................................._............ 225 ...................................7026
Lenczewski, Ann (DFL)........................................ 237 ...................................4218
Lesch, John (DFL).................................................. 223 ...................................4224
Liebling, Tina (DFL) .............................................. 393 ...................................0573
Lieder, Bernie (DFL).............................................. 323 ...................................5091
Lillie, Leon (DFL)...................................uu............. 353...................................1188
Loeffler, Diane (DFL) ............................................ 307 ...................................4219
Magnus, Doug (R)................................................. 515 ...................................5505
Mahoney, Tim (DFL)............................................. 289...................................4277
Mariani, Carlos (DFL) ........................................... 203...................................9714
Marquart, Paul (DFL) ........................................... 345...................................6829
McNamara, Denny (R) ......................................... 431 ...................................3135
Meslow, Doug (R) ................................................. 531 ...................................5363
Mae, Frank (DFL)................................................... 369 ...................................5515
Mullery, Joe (DFL) ................................................. 367 ...................................4262
Murphy, Mary (DFL)............................................. 343 ...................................2676
Nelson, Michael (DFL) .........................................317...................................3751
Nelson, Peter (R).................................................... 433...................................5377
Newman, Scott (R) ............................................... 569 ...................................1534
Nornes, Bud (R)...................................................... 471 ...................................4946
Olson, Mark (R) ...................................................... 501 ...................................4237
Otremba, Mary Ellen (DFL)................................ 247 ...................................3201
Ozment, Dennis (R) .............................................. 479 ...................................4306
Paulsen, Erik (R) .....................................................459 ...................................7449
Paymar, Michael (DFL) ........................................ 253 ...................................4199
Pelowski, Jr., Gene (DFL) .................................... 295 ...................................8637
Penas, Maxine (R).................................................. 579 ...................................9635
Peppin, Joyce (R)................................................... 411...................................7806
Peterson, Aaron (DFL) ......................................... 351 ...................................4228
Peterson, Neil W. (R}............................................. 527 ...................................7803
Peterson, Sandra (DFL) ....................................... 213...................................4176
Poppe, Jeanne (DFL)............................................ 231 ...................................4193
Powell, Du ke (R) .................................................... 407 ...................................4212
Rukavina, Tom {DFL}............................................ 279 ...................................0170
Ruth, Connie (R) .................................................... 565 ...................................5368
Ruud, Maria (DFL) ................................................. 311 ...................................3964
Sailer, Brita (DFL)................................................... 327...................................4265
Samuelson, Char (R) ............................................ 415...................................0141
Scalze, Bev (DFL).................................................. 241 ...................................7153
Seifert, Marty (R) ................................................... 381 ..................................5374
Sertich, Anthony "Tony" (DFL).......................... 273 ...................................0172
Severson, Dan (R) ................................................. 553 ...................................7808
5ieben, Katie (DFL) ............................................. 215 ...................................4342
Simen, Steve (DFL) ............................................... 313 ...................................9889
Simpson, Dean (R) ................................................ 525...................................4293
Slawik, Nora (DFL) ................................................ 357 ...................................7807
5mith, 5teve (R) ..................................................... 543 ...................................9188
Soderstrom, Judy (R) ........................................... 439 ...................................0518
Solberg, Loren (DFL)........................................... 349 ...................................2365
Sviggum, Steve (R) ............................................... 463...................................2273
Sykora, Barb (R) ..................................................... 485...................................4315
Thao, Cy (DFL) ........................................................ 359 ...................................5158
Thissen, Paul (DFL) ............................................... 301...................................5375
Tingelstad, Kathy (R) ............................................ 403 ...................................5369
Urdahl, Dean (R) .................................................... 521 ...................................4344
Vandeveer, Ray (R)................................................ 583 ...................................4124
Wagenius, Jean (DFL) .......................................... 251 ...................................4200
Walker, Neva (DFL) .........................,........,............ 209 ............................,......7152
Wardlow, Lynn (R)................................................. 491 ...................................4128
Weltl, Andy (DFL) .................................................. 387...................................4378
Westerberg, Andrew"Andy" (R)....................... 549 ...................................4226
Westrom, Torrey (R).............................................. 533 ...................................4929
Wilkin, Tim (R) ........................................................ 551 ...................................3533
Zellers, Kurt (R) ...................................................... 557 ...................................5502
4A
58A
6B
46A
17B
18A
lOA
16B
llB
37B
42B
64B
31A
lA
32A
20A
41B
45A
27B
40A
5A
26A
42A
2B
50B
54B
21A
5B
14A
57A
44A
lOB
55B
33A
8B
3B
28B
33B
65A
63A
49B
18B
52A
62B
61B
38B
30B
51A
llA
38A
32B
House Public Information Services Office. 175 State Office Building. 51. Paui, MN 55155 . (651) 296.2146
This document can be made available in alternative formats to individuals with disabilities by calling (651) 296~2146 voice, (651) 296-9896 TTY, or (800) 657-3550 toll free voice and TTY.
.AlI rooms are in the State Office Building unless otherwise noted, St. Paul, MN SSlS5
memo as of Jan, 24,2006
2006 Minnesota Senate Members
Distrlct/Mem ber /Pa rty
Room'
Phone
(651) 296- District/Member/Party Room'
_._m.__._"".______._n_.__..""_.__________.___..___.'",._...___._____,_,__._..__..__.._......._.___....._,..._..._.....-------~---,-,....---.-.
Phone
(651) 296-
66
52
6
40
61
51
43
50
15
64
26
60
18
14
47
21
37
42
58
23
13
Anderson, Ellen (DFL) ...................................... 1 20 Cap......................................................553 7
Bachmann, Michele (R)..,...........................,..... 141 50B ....................................................,4351
Bakk, Thomas (DFL) ..........................................226 Cap .................................................8881
Belanger, William (R)........................,.,..............l 1 3508..........................,..........................5975
Berglin, Linda (OFL) ..........................................309 Cap. .."'............."'............."'............"'.426 1
Betzold, Don (DFL) .,...,...................................... 111 Cap....................,.................................2556
Bonoff, Terri (OFL) "'................."'."'...................325 Cap.............."'........,..................."'.....,4314
Chaudhary, 5atveer IOFLI...............................3 17 Cap......................................................4334
Cia rk, Ta rryl (DR) ........"'................."'............ .... 303 Ca p. ...................... ................."'... ...."'.64 55
Cohen, Richard (DFL) ....................................... 121 Cap............"'...............................,.......5931
Day, Dick (R)..............."'............."'........."'..."'.....147 SOB ....."'...................................."''''...9457
Dibble, o. Scott (OFL) ...........,.................."'...... 1 1 1 Cap............"'.,.....................................41 91
Dille, Steve IR) ....."'.............................................1 03 SOB .."'................................................4131
Fischbach, Michelle (R) ....................................G- 15 SOB .................................,.................2084
Foley, Leo (DFL) ..............,.................,.................G.24 Cap........,..................,"'.....................4 1 54
Frederickson, Dennis (R) ........................,........ 1 39 SOB .....,...............................................8138
Gerlach, Chris (R) ,.....................................,.,.,.... 107 SOB .......................,...............,............,4 120
Hann, David (RI.....,.............................................G-27 SOB ,.................................................. 1 749
Hi9gins, Linda 10FLI ..............................,..........328 Cap...........,...,................"'...................9246
Hottinger, John (OFL).......................................317 Cap..........................................."'........6153
Johnson, Dean (DR) ........................................208 Cap................................................,.....3826
Jch:1so:1, Debb!€ (R~ .........................................135 SOB ..........................m.................,......3219
Jung bauer, Michael (RI .................................,..G.25 SOB ....,..............................................3733
Kelley, Steve I DFl) ............................................. 205 Ca p... ................"'........."'..........."'.. 7-8065
Kierlin, Bob (R) .................................."'.."',.........127 SOB .............,..,........................."'........5649
Kiscaden, Shei la (DFL) .................................."'. 325 Cap. ........................."'.........................4848
Koch, Amy T. (R) .................,..."'.................."'."', 11 5 SOB ."'......................"'........................5981
Koering, Paul (RI......"'.........................."'...........131 SOB ..........."'................"'......"'..."'....,4875
Ku biy, Ga ry (OF L) ............................................... 306 Cap. .....................................................5094
Langseth, Keith IDFL) ..."'........................"'...... 122 Cap. ........................"'..........................3205
Larson, Cal (R) ."'................"'..............................153 SOB ......................................."'...........5655
LeClair, Brian (R) ................................................. 129 SOB .....................................................4 166
Limmer, Warren (R).................,..........................12 1 SOB .........................."'........................2159
Lourey, Becky (OFL) ............."'..........................G-24 Cap....................................................0293
57
54
38
39
41
67
28
25
17
33
34
65
36
59
63
53
45
35
24
4
11
3
46
29
2
62
7
27
1
5
22
16
55
Marko, Sharon IDFL) ........................"'.............. G-24 Cap...."'......................................... 7-8060
Marty, John (DFL) ............................,................. 323 Cap. .....................,..,............................5645
McGinn, Mike (R)........"'....."''''..'''.....................G-19 SOB .............................................,.7-8073
Metzen, James (DFL) ........................................322 Cap. ....."'.............................................4370
Michel, Geoff (R)..."'........"'.."'........................... 133 SOB ..........."'..............................."'.....6238
Moua, Mee (OFL) ................... ............................. 23 5 Ca p. ..................................................... 5 285
Murp hy, 5 teve I DF L) ............................."'......... 306 Cap. ..................."''''.'''........................4264
Neuville, Thomas (R)......................................... 1 23 SOB .....................................................1279
Nienow, Sean (R)............."'....."'................."'....1 05 SOB ............"'..........."'................"'.....5419
Olson, Gen (R) ..................................................... 119 SOB ........"'."'......................................1282
Ortman, Julianne (R)..........."''''.......'''..............G-2 1 508................."'...............................4837
Pappas, Sandra (DFL) ..."'................................. 1 20 Cap. .................."'................................ 1 802
Pariseau, Pat (R)......"'......................................... 1 1 7 SOB ..........."'.......................................5252
Pogemiller, Lawrence (DFLI ................"'........ 235 Cap....................................,................. 7809
Ranum, Jane (DFl) ............................................120 Cap........................................"'.......7-8061
Reiter, Mady (R) .................................................. 1320 SOB ..........,......,..............,.............,...1253
Rest, Ann (OFL) ....,....,..............................,..........205 Cap. ........,...........................................,2889
Robling, Claire (R) ......................,.....,...........,..... 1 43 SOB ................,.,.."'."'."'..,.........."'.....4123
Rosen, Julie (R)..............."'...,.............,................G-23 SOB ......."'......,....,.........,......,............5713
Ruud, Carrie IRI......."'..........,..........,................'" 1 09 SOB .............................................."'....4913
Sams, DallaslDFL) .............................................328 Cap..............................,...................7-8063
Saxhallg, Tom IDFL) ......124 Cap. .. ......"'. ........... ..4136
Scheid, Linda IDFl) ...........................................303 Cap. ............,.................................."'...8869
5enjem, David (RI ."'..........."'...................."'.....145 508.,"'....................."',.......................3903
5koe, Rod (OFL) .........,........................................ 124 Cap. ............................,...........,............4196
Skoglund, Wesley (DFL) ........................,,,,.....,.124 Cap. ............"',............................,........4274
Solon, Yvonne Prettner (OFL) ........................ 303 Cap. ..............."'.......,...........................4188
Sparks, Dan (DFL) .................,........................;...G-24 Cap.................................................,..9248
Stumpf, LeRoy (DFL) ......................................... G.24 Cap...............,.,..................................8660
Tomassoni, David IDFL)..."'................,............321 Cap.............,...........,..,.,.......................801 7
Vickerma n, Jim (OFLI........................................ 226 Cap. ......".................,.................,.........5650
Wergin, Betsy IR),.....,.,................................"'..,. 1 25 SOB ..............,........................,.......,....,8075
Wiger, Charies (DR) ..........................,.,............301 Cap. .........................,..........,......,.........6820
.Capitol or State Office Building, St. Paul, MN 551 S5
49
48
44
31
30
19
12
20
9
10
56
32
8
Minnesota House and Senate Membership
1 A Rep. Maxine Penas-{R) 15 A Rep. Jim Knobiach-(RI 29 A Rep. Randy Demmer-(RI 43 A Rep. Jeff Johnson-(R) 57 A Rep. Katie Sleben-(DFL)
B Rep. 8ernie Lieder-(DFll B Rep. Larry Haws-(DFU B Rep. Fran Bradley-(R) B Rep. Ron Abrams-IR) B Rep. Denny McNamara.(RI
Sen. LeRoy A. Stumpf-(DFl) Sen. Tarryl C1ark.(DFl} Sen, David H. Senjem-(RI Sen. Terri Bonoff-(DFLI Sen. Sharon Marko-(DFL)
2 A Rep. Kent Eken-IDFl) 16 A Rep. Sondra Erickson-(R) 30 A Rep. Tina Liebiing-(DFll 44 A Rep. Steve Simon.(DFl} 58 A Rep. Joe Mullery-(DFl)
B Rep. Brita Sailer-(DFl) B Rep. Mark Olson-(R) B Rep. Andy Weiti-IDFlI B Rep. Ron latz-(DFll B Rep. Keith Eilison-(DFL)
Sen. Rod 5koe-(DFll Sen. Betsy L Wergin-(RI Sen. Sheila M. Kiscaden-(lP) Sen. Steve Kelley-(DFll Sen.linda Higgins-(DFl)
3 A Rep. irv Anderson-(DFll 17 A Rep. Rob Eastlund-(R) 31 A Rep. Gene Pelowski Jr.-(DFl) 45 A Rep. Sandra Peterson-(DFll 59 A Rep. Diane Loeffler.(DFl)
8 Rep. Loren A. Soiberg-(DFl) B Rep. Peter Nelson-(RI B Rep. Gregory M. Davids-(RI B Rep.lyndon R. Carlson-(DFll B Rep. Phyllis Kahn-IDFLI
Sen. Tom Saxhau9-(DFl) Sen. Sean R. Nienow-(R) Sen. Bob Kierlin-IR) Sen. Ann H. Rest-(DFl) Sen.lawrence J. Pogemilier-(DFL)
4 A Rep. Frank Moe-(DFl) 18 A Rep. Scott Newman.(RI 32 A Rep. Joyce Peppin-(RI 46 A Rep. Michaei Nelson.(DFll 60 A Rep. Margaret Anderson Kelliher-(DFlI
B Rep.larry Howes-(R) B Rep. Dean UrdahHRI B Rep. Kurt Zellers.(R} B Rep. Debra Hilstrom-IDFl) B Rep. Frank Hornstein.(DFL)
Sen. Carrie L Ruud-IR) Sen. Steve Dille-IR) Sen. Warren Limmer-(R) Sen. Linda Scheid-IDFll Sen. D. Scott Dibble-IDFLI
5 A Rep. Tom Rukavina-(DFl) 19 A Rep. BrllCe Anderson-(R) 33 A Rep. Steve Smith-(R) 47 A Rep. Denise Dittnch-(DFLI 61 A Rep. Karen C1ark-IDFL}
B Rep.Anthony"Tony"5ertich-(OFl) B Rep. Tom Emmer-{RI B Rep. Barb Sykora-(R) B Rep. Meiissa Hortman-(DFl) B Rep. Neva Walker-(DFl)
Sen. David J. Tomassoni-(DFll Sen. Amy T Koch-(RI Sen. Gen Olson-(RI Sen.leo Foley-IDFl) Sen. Linda Berglin-IDFll
--.--- --..---.-----..-- ----..-------...---....-. ---....-------".--.-..-....-..-.-
6 A Rep. David Dill-(DFLI 20 A Rep. Aaron Peterson-IDFL) 34 A Rep. Paul Kohls-(R) 48 A Rep. Tom Hackbarth-IR) 62 A Rep. Jim Davnie-(DFl)
8 Rep. Ya~y MI;rphy-iDFI } B Rep Lyle KOf>nel"l-(OI=U B Rep. Joe Hopoe-(R! B Rep. Jim Abeier.(RI B Rep, Jean Wagenj'Js.(DFLl
Sen. Thomas M. Bakk.(DFl) Sen. Gary Kubly-(DFLI Sen. Julianne E. Ortman-(RI Sen. Michaei J. Jungbauer.(R) Sen. Wesley J. Skoglund-(DFL)
7 A Rep. Thomas Huntley-(DFl) 21 A Rep. Marty Seifert-IRI 35 A Rep. Michael Beard-IR) 49 A Rep. Chris DelaForest-(RI 63 A Rep. Paui Thissen-(DFll
B Rep. Mike Jaros-(DFl) 8 Rep. Brad Finstad-(RI B Rep. Mark Buesgens-IR) B Rep. KathyTlngelstad-(R) B Rep. Dan larson-(DFLI
Sen. Yvonne Prettner SoJon-(DFLl Sen. Dennis R. Frederickson-{R) ..Sen. Claire A. Robiing-(RI Sen. Debbie J. Johnson-(R) Sen. Jane B. Ranum-(DFLI
8 A Rep. Bill Hiity-IDFl} 22 A Rep. Doug Magnus-(R) 36 A Rep. Mary Liz Holberg-(R) 50 A Rep. Barbara Goodwin-(DFll 64 A Rep. Matt Entenza-(DFl)
B Rep. Judy Soderstrom-(R) B Rep. Rod Hamilton-(RI B Rep. Pat Garofalo-(RI B Rep. Char Samueison-(RI B Rep. Michael Paymar-(DFl}
Sen. Becky lourey-(DFl) Sen. Jim Vickerman-(DFl) Sen. Pat Pariseau-(R) Sen. Satveer Chaudhary-(DFl) Sen. Richard), Cohen-(DFLI
9 A Rep. Morrie Lanning-(R) 23 A Rep. Ruth Johnson-(OFL) 37 A Rep. Lloyd Cybart-(RI 51 A Rep. Andrew"Andy"Westerberg{R) 6 5 A Rep. Cy Thao-(DFl)
B Rep. Paul Marquart-(DFll B Rep, John Dorn-IDFll B Rep. Dennis OzmenHR) B Rep. Connie Bernardy-(DFl) B Rep. Carlos Mariani-IDFll
Sen. Keith langseth-(DFl) Sen. John C. Hottinger-(DFU Sen. Chris Gerlach-(R) Sen. Don Betzold.(OFl) Sen. Sandra L Pappas-(DFLI
10 A Rep. Bud Nornes-(R) 24 A Rep. Bob Gunther-(RI 38 A Rep. Tim Wilkin-(R) 52 A Rep. Ray Vandeveer-(RI 66 A Rep. John lesch-(DFL)
B Rep. Dean Simpson-(R) B Rep. Tony Cornish-IR) B Rep. Lynn Wardlow.(R) B Rep. Matt Dean-(R) B Rep. Alice Hausman-(DFl)
Sen. Callarson-(R) Sen. Julie Rosen-(Rl Sen. Mike McGinn-(R) Sen. Michele Bachmann-(R) Sen. Elien R. Anderson-IDFL)
11 A Rep. Torrey Westrom-(R) 25 A Rep. laura Brod-(RI 39 A Rep. Rick Hansen-(DFll 53 A Rep. Philip Krinkie-(RI 67 A Rep. Tim Mahoney.(DFl)
B Rep. Mary Ellen Otremba-IDFL) B Rep. Raymond Cox-(R) B Rep. Joseph Atkins-(DFL) B Rep. Doug Meslow-(R) B Rep. Sheldon Johnson-(DFl)
Sen. Dalias C. Sams-(DFU Sen. Thomas M. Neuville-(RI Sen. James P Metzen-(DFll Sen. Mady Reiter-IRI Sen. Mee Moua-IDFl)
--.-....---- -..-.------..-......--.---..-- --.---------- --.---
12 A Rep. Paul Gazelka-(R) 26 A Rep. Connie Ruth-(R) 40 A Rep. Duke Powell-(R) 54 A Rep. Mindy Greiling-(DFl)
B Rep. Greg Blaine-IRI B Rep. Patti Fritz-IOFlI B Rep. Ann lenczewski-(DFl) B Rep. Bev Scalze-(DFl)
Sen. Paul E. Koering.IRI Sen. Dick Day-IRI Sen. William V. Belanger Jr.-(R) Sen. John Marty.IDFll This document can be made
.---.-.-....-......-..------- .---...--.-----..-.------ ---.------.--.-.--.-- -. ----..- available in alternative
13 A Rep. Bud Heidgerken-(R) 27 A Rep. Dan Dorman-(RI 41 A Rep. Ron Erhardt-(RI 55 A Rep. leon Lillie-IDFl) formats for people with disabilities by
B Rep. AI Juhnke-IDFll B Rep. Jeanne Poppe-(DFlI B Rep. Neli W Peterson-(RI B Rep..Nora Slawik-(DFU calling the House at
Sen. Dean E. Johnson-(DFl) Sen. Dan Sparks-IDFLI Sen. GeoH Michel-(RI Sen. Charles IChuck) W Wiger-(OFLI (651)296-2146 voice,
14 A Rep. Daniel Severson-(R) 28 A Rep. Jerry Dempsey.(R) 42 A Rep. Maria Ruud-(DFLI 56 A Rep. Mike Charron-IRI (651l296-9896 TrY or the Senate at
8 Rep. Larry Hosch-(DFll B Rep. Steve Sviggum-(R) B Rep. Erik Paulsen-(R) B Rep. Karen Klinzing-(RI 165 11 296.QS04 voice
Sen. Micheile l. Fischbach-IR) Sen. Steve Murphy-(DFl) Sen. David Hann-(R) Sen. Brian leClair-(R) or 16511 296.Q2S0TTY